People out­side law en­force­ment some­times have the im­pres­sion that if only of­fi­cers would con­sis­tently try to de-es­ca­late stand­offs with dis­turbed in­di­vid­u­als with weap­ons, shoot­ings could al­ways be avoided — as though de-es­ca­la­tion were a mir­a­cle cure. But there is no mir­a­cle cure.

Re­cent re­port­ing has high­lighted the prev­a­lence of shoot­ings by po­lice of peo­ple wield­ing knives and other edged weap­ons. These cases, of­ten in­volv­ing in­di­vid­u­als in cri­sis, show two deadly prob­lems: There are lim­its to what “de-es­ca­la­tion” can ac­com­plish and of­fi­cers too of­ten hes­i­tate to use non­le­thal force, al­low­ing stand­offs to spi­ral out of con­trol.

Hesi­ta­tion to shoot

Across the coun­try in re­cent years, of­fi­cers of­ten seem re­luc­tant to use le­git­i­mate force to end a stand­off in­ci­dent when ver­bal at­tempts fail to in­spire the sub­ject to give up. This hes­i­ta­tion to use even non­le­thal weap­ons — in sit­u­a­tions that clearly call for them — of­ten leads to a po­lice shoot­ing, be­cause at some point as de-es­ca­la­tion ef­forts drag on fruit­lessly, sus­pects may sud­denly at­tack.

To be sure, de-es­ca­la­tion is a cru­cial tool for po­lice of­fi­cers. It is one of the first things I learned as a rookie cop in 1976: Talk in­stead of fight, if the sit­u­a­tion al­lows the choice.

Advertise with us

The hope in en­gag­ing the re­sist­ing sub­ject in ef­fec­tive com­mu­ni­ca­tions is to lower the in­ten­sity of the in­ci­dent and per­suade him or her to sub­mit. It works when it works (which is the norm), and it doesn’t work when it doesn’t.

This is where the deadly mis­take of­ten lies: rec­og­niz­ing that de-es­ca­la­tion is not work­ing, but be­ing re­luc­tant to use non­le­thal force be­cause of fear of the ad­min­is­tra­tive, le­gal and me­dia af­ter­math.

One sees the pat­tern when po­lice are in a stand­off with some­one who is armed with a knife. The norm would be for of­fi­cers to keep their dis­tance, to talk to the in­di­vid­ual and lis­ten, to keep com­mu­ni­ca­tion go­ing as an ef­fort to re­solve the sit­u­a­tion peace­fully.

In­stead, with the best of in­ten­tions, some­times of­fi­cers “talk the per­son to death.” When po­lice fail to rec­og­nize that talk isn’t work­ing, then of­fi­cers de­cline to use non­le­thal means such as Tasers to sub­due an armed in­di­vid­ual, the re­sult of­ten goes the other way.

The in­di­vid­ual grows more agi­tated the lon­ger the stand­off drags on and charges with the knife at of­fi­cers or by­stand­ers. This is when shoot­ings oc­cur.

Advertise with us

Each case on its mer­its

If only of­fi­cers had aban­doned de-es­ca­la­tion on their own terms in­stead of wait­ing for the sus­pect to end it by at­tack­ing. If only the of­fi­cers had used a Taser or other non­le­thal op­tion and saved a life — not to men­tion avoided an ex­pen­sive shoot­ing in­ves­ti­ga­tion and lit­i­ga­tion — in­stead of “talk­ing the per­son to death.”

As a long­time con­sul­tant on po­lice use of force, I be­lieve that of­fi­cers should use talk in most sit­u­a­tions but must as­sess each case on its own mer­its for how long they will talk with­out act­ing. It seems likely to me that of­fi­cers have be­come gun shy be­cause so many col­leagues have faced back­lash af­ter shoot­ings, but no one’s in­ter­est is served by ex­tend­ing this at­ti­tude to non­le­thal force.

Don’t let an over­em­pha­sis on de-es­ca­la­tion put ci­vil­ians’ and of­fi­cers’ lives at risk. Don’t hes­i­tate to use tools such as Tasers and other force op­tions when ap­pro­pri­ate. Fewer and less se­vere in­ju­ries from non­le­thal weap­ons are pref­er­a­ble to avoid­able shoot­ings.

A hope that all po­lice stand­offs could end with talk is un­re­al­is­tic. But can most end with talk or non­le­thal means? Ab­so­lutely — and in fact most stand­offs al­ready do.

Make ex­cep­tions rare

The ex­cep­tions that be­come shoot­ings are the cases that make the head­lines. We can make those ex­cep­tions more rare with bet­ter pol­icy and train­ing and a cul­tural shift that en­cour­ages use of non­le­thal weap­ons at the right mo­ments.

Advertise with us

The pub­lic and the me­dia have a role to play. Just as pub­lic pres­sure and equip­ping of­fi­cers with a va­ri­ety of non­le­thal weap­ons have con­trib­uted to re­duc­ing the fre­quency of po­lice shoot­ings com­pared with de­cades ago, pub­lic sup­port can make a dif­fer­ence for of­fi­cers and de­part­ments that use lower lev­els of force — be­fore a stand­off sit­u­a­tion be­comes a shoot­ing.

Greg Meyer, an ex­pert on po­lice use of force, is a re­tired Los An­ge­les Po­lice Depart­ment cap­tain who con­ducted the de­part­ment’s non­le­thal weap­ons re­search, test­ing and train­ing in 1979-80.