The uni­lat­eral de­ci­sion by Pres­i­dent Joe Biden’s ad­min­is­tra­tion to for­give stu­dent loan debt is driv­ing a cul­ture of stu­dent bor­rower ir­re­spon­si­bil­ity in which debt re­pay­ment is con­sid­ered op­tional, and our stu­dents are worse off for it.

For­giv­ing stu­dent loan debt was one of his big­gest 2020 cam­paign prom­ises. Young peo­ple voted for Biden in droves. He de­ci­sively won the de­mo­graphic of vot­ers younger than 44.

Eras­ing debt

Over the course of his pres­i­dency, Biden tried a num­ber of times and a num­ber of dif­fer­ent ways to make good on his prom­ise.

Ini­tially, the White House re­leased a plan that granted roughly 43 mil­lion peo­ple the abil­ity to get up to $20,000 of stu­dent debt for­given. En­su­ing le­gal chal­lenges in the Supreme Court quashed that pro­gram, but the White House con­tin­ued to whee­dle its way to­ward its ob­jec­tives.

Advertise with us

Thus far, the Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion has erased more than $144 bil­lion in stu­dent loan debt, le­ver­ag­ing var­i­ous pro­grams and sys­tems to end-run Con­gress and the courts — both of whom have sig­naled their dis­ap­proval.

For the bor­row­ers, the pros­pect of free money has been wel­come. How­ever, the re­al­ity of stu­dent loan for­give­ness is much more nu­anced, com­pli­cated and det­ri­men­tal to Amer­i­can mer­i­toc­racy, a core tenet upon which the na­tion was built.

The White House’s piece­meal plan to wipe out stu­dent loan debt sends the wrong mes­sage about per­sonal ac­count­abil­ity and fis­cal re­spon­si­bil­ity. It is set­ting stu­dents up for fail­ures that will be more pain­ful than writ­ing a monthly loan re­pay­ment check.

For tax­pay­ers, as well as busi­ness own­ers like me, stu­dent loan for­give­ness hasn’t been the pan­a­cea it has been for stu­dents — in fact, it’s been quite the op­po­site. In ad­di­tion to va­por­iz­ing tax­payer money, the debt for­give­ness ju­bi­lee is mak­ing it harder to col­lect money still owed for ed­u­ca­tional ser­vices. Many stu­dents that take on the most debt no lon­ger be­lieve they need to pay for cur­ric­u­lum-based pro­grams, re­gard­less of their qual­ity.

Dire mes­sag­ing

There can be a place for cir­cum­stances and pro­grams that of­fer debt for­give­ness or tu­i­tion guar­an­tees. The U.S. mil­i­tary has suc­cess­fully used pro­grams such as the GI Bill to of­fer vet­er­ans a path­way to ca­reer suc­cess that may not oth­er­wise be avail­able to them. This is earned through ser­vice to our coun­try — the op­er­a­tive word be­ing “earned.”

Advertise with us

Un­like the GI Bill or ROTC schol­ar­ships, the cur­rent stu­dent loan for­give­ness pro­gram re­wards with­out dis­cre­tion. It is cre­at­ing a sys­tem of mis­aligned in­cen­tives — one that in no way ties ac­a­demic suc­cess to the prom­ise of loan for­give­ness.

The mes­sag­ing is dire for tax­pay­ers and those who paid their loans: Bor­row what­ever you would like, and the gov­ern­ment and tax­pay­ers will pick up the tab. Wouldn’t it be a bet­ter idea if the gov­ern­ment was, in some way, mak­ing sure that those re­ceiv­ing loan for­give­ness were those who put the loan to its best use?

Imag­ine if each loan for­give­ness case was eval­u­ated by cri­te­ria such as: How did the stu­dent per­form in class? Did the stu­dent at­tend classes reg­u­larly? Did this stu­dent make a sin­cere at­tempt to pay back even part of the loan? Did this stu­dent grad­u­ate and gen­u­inely seek em­ploy­ment? Did the stu­dent se­cure a job in their field of study?

An ac­count­abil­ity ru­bric would set clear ex­pec­ta­tions for the stu­dent and school alike. It would also es­tab­lish a sense of ur­gency and fis­cal re­spon­si­bil­ity among bor­row­ers, not to men­tion drive em­ploy­ment out­comes.

This al­go­rithm shouldn’t just be for stu­dents, ei­ther. Col­leges and uni­ver­sities that are charg­ing egre­gious tu­i­tion fees and costs should face the same mu­sic.

Advertise with us

Re­quir­ing greater trans­par­ency from higher ed­u­ca­tion in­sti­tu­tions would not only give stu­dents a bet­ter un­der­stand­ing of what they’re pay­ing for, but would also push the schools to de­lin­eate funds to ed­u­ca­tional ser­vices that have the high­est im­pact for the stu­dents, ser­vices that pre­pare them for the 21st cen­tury work­force.

Demand ac­count­abil­ity

Be­fore the fed­eral gov­ern­ment cat­e­gor­i­cally waives stu­dent debt, tax­pay­ers should de­mand an ac­count­abil­ity ru­bric on a per-stu­dent ba­sis that jus­ti­fies hav­ing their debt can­celed.

The cur­rent sys­tem is not fi­nan­cially sus­tain­able, nor does it send the right mes­sage about pur­su­ing the Amer­i­can dream. We need a stan­dard­ized ru­bric that gauges whether stu­dents qual­ify for stu­dent loan for­give­ness, and, if so, how much.

This sys­tem would drive bi­di­rec­tional ac­count­abil­ity, both for the stu­dent and the ed­u­ca­tion pro­vider. It would also help tax­pay­ers sleep bet­ter at night while Biden is writ­ing checks on their be­half.

Jen­ni­fer Sch­wab is founder and CEO of Entity Acad­emy.