By 2030, we’ll no lon­ger be re­pro­duc­ing fast enough to re­place our­selves. As re­cently as 2017, the United Na­tions pre­dicted hu­man num­bers wouldn’t peak un­til 2100 when we’d reach more than 11 bil­lion peo­ple.

Ac­cord­ing to the new es­ti­mate, pub­lished in the English med­i­cal jour­nal The Lan­cet, our num­bers could rise from the cur­rent 8.1 bil­lion to a max­i­mum of just 9.5 bil­lion be­fore de­clin­ing by the early 2060s. We’re not about to suf­fer a pop­u­la­tion over­shoot and run out of food, as some­times hap­pens to an­i­mals in the wild — and as was pre­dicted in the 1968 book, “The Pop­u­la­tion Bomb.”

But the rel­a­tive num­ber of older peo­ple will sky­rocket around the world, caus­ing anx­i­ety among some econ­o­mists, and some po­lit­i­cal lead­ers want more peo­ple to have more kids. On the other side, some en­vi­ron­men­tal­ists ar­gue for push­ing pop­u­la­tion to drop faster to slow global warm­ing and loss of hab­i­tat for other spe­cies and ul­ti­mately for us hu­mans.

At the core of the de­bate are big, un­an­swered ques­tions: Is 9.5 bil­lion too many peo­ple? Will the pop­u­la­tion sub­se­quently fall to a num­ber that’s too low? Is there a right num­ber of hu­mans?

Advertise with us

Fo­cus on chil­dren, not births

Maybe in­stead of fo­cus­ing on the num­ber of chil­dren peo­ple are hav­ing, pol­i­cy­mak­ers should fo­cus on the fact that too many chil­dren world­wide aren’t get­ting ade­quate nu­tri­tion, ed­u­ca­tion or med­i­cal care.

Even now, though hu­mans grow enough food to feed ev­ery­one, roughly one per­son in 10 is chron­i­cally un­der­nour­ished — that’s sci­en­tific jar­gon for “hun­gry all the time.” More than one child in five is stunted (too short) be­cause of chronic hun­ger and in­fec­tions.

After all, as de­mog­ra­pher and math­e­ma­ti­cian Joel Co­hen ex­plains, the “right num­ber of peo­ple” ques­tion de­pends on yet more ques­tions, among them: What would be the ac­cepted stan­dard of ma­terial wealth? How much in­equal­ity would be ac­cept­able? Would it be okay to build cit­ies in ar­eas prone to cat­a­strophic flood­ing and earth­quakes? Do peo­ple pre­fer park­ing lots or parks?

Co­hen says the new Lan­cet es­ti­mate is cred­i­ble. “This is re­ally the most se­ri­ous piece of work in the busi­ness about what has hap­pened and what to ex­pect,” he said. “There are lots of con­nec­tions to cli­mate, re­li­gion, eco­nom­ics, pol­i­tics — but the fact is that fer­til­ity has been go­ing down and is likely to con­tinue to go down.”

Fer­til­ity is usu­ally mea­sured by look­ing at the num­ber of chil­dren born each year to women of each age, from 15 to 55. But the Lan­cet model fol­lows co­horts of women born each year — count­ing the ba­bies born to women who turned 15 in 1950, then 16 in 1950, and so on — up un­til the time they turn 50.

Advertise with us

Unin­tended con­se­quences

“Co­hort fer­til­ity is a much bet­ter sum­mary of the real ex­pe­ri­ence of real women,” Co­hen said. The new pro­jec­tion also fac­tored in the es­ti­mated ef­fects on ed­u­ca­tion and ac­cess to con­tra­cep­tion, both of which have a big ef­fect on re­duc­ing fer­til­ity.

At­tempts by some gov­ern­ments to en­cour­age par­ent­hood with eco­nomic in­cen­tives or abor­tion re­stric­tions are fail­ing, he said. He pointed to a pa­per in the Jour­nal of the Amer­i­can Med­i­cal As­so­ci­a­tion show­ing that rates of vol­un­tary ster­il­iza­tion rose af­ter the Supreme Court’s Dobbs de­ci­sion re­voked na­tional abor­tion rights. Though cause and ef­fect aren’t proven, it’s pos­si­ble that re­stric­tive abor­tion laws are “push­ing peo­ple out of re­pro­duc­tion … which I don’t think is the in­tended ef­fect.”

It’s im­pos­sible to know all the un­in­tended con­se­quences of try­ing to en­gi­neer the pop­u­la­tion to grow, or shrink, but there’s no down­side to tak­ing bet­ter care of the chil­dren we al­ready have.

The fo­cus of fu­ture pol­icy should be to help peo­ple have the num­ber of kids they want, when they want, with whom they want. In her new book “Sex and the Planet,” Univer­sity of Utah bio­eth­i­cist Mar­ga­ret Pabst Bat­tin starts with a thought ex­per­i­ment: What would hap­pen if ev­ery­one had ac­cess to re­li­able, safe, free, fool­proof long-term con­tra­cep­tion, so that get­ting preg­nant would only hap­pen if a woman or cou­ple opted in?

Too many or too few

Right now, 45% of preg­nan­cies world­wide (and a higher pro­por­tion in the U.S.) are un­planned, and some of those lead to the 73 mil­lion abor­tions that take place ev­ery year. With re­li­able long-term birth con­trol, the rates of abor­tion would plum­met, as would the rates of teen preg­nancy.

Advertise with us

Birth rates in many re­gions would go down, which would pre­vent rapid pop­u­la­tion growth. People would not need to re­sort to per­ma­nent ster­il­iza­tion.

Gloom and doom sells, of course, which is why pop­u­la­tion trends al­ways tend to be framed as im­pend­ing di­sas­ters — whether they are baby booms or baby busts. If we can’t agree whether we’re fac­ing too many or too few peo­ple, per­haps it’s a good time to help peo­ple have the num­ber of chil­dren they think is right for them.

F.D. Flam is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and host of the “Follow the Science” podcast. Her previous article was “Americans sleep more but still feel more tired.”