I started reporting on COVID in February 2020. It was already clear that a catastrophe was hurtling toward us. But people who took that fact seriously were often pooh-poohed as alarmist, doomers or preppers because many health officials were downplaying the threat.
The next month, startled by the official claims that masks were harmful, I begged the authorities to level with the public about the potential benefits of masking rather than seemingly tailoring their message to avoid panic over the supply shortage. That strategy, I noted, was sure to backfire — as it did.
The questions around masks led me to the 6-foot rule and the debate over how COVID was spread. “FACT CHECK: COVID-19 is NOT airborne,” the World Health Organization declared on social media — even though SARS, a virus very much like COVID, had long since been understood to be airborne.
Frustrated scientists pleaded with the CDC and the WHO to take into account the new evidence. By the way, as of this writing, that “fact check” post is still up.
I later implored the authorities to open parks (that was April 2020) as well as to recognize airborne transmission and the protective effect of ventilation and to stop shaming people for going to the beach (both in July 2020). I even joined some of those scientists to write articles in peer-reviewed scientific journals.
Afraid to tell the truth
But as I reported on these topics, one theme kept coming up: High-level officials were afraid to tell the truth — or just to admit that they didn’t have all the answers — lest they spook the public.
Read More
It emerged during these congressional hearings that U.S. scientific authorities had no idea what viruses the Wuhan lab was using or what work it was doing. So how could they issue all those confident assurances?
The hearings occasionally turned into a clown show, with some lawmakers looking to score cheap political points. But others pulled their punches, no doubt worried about validating the misinformation that swirls around these issues. This attitude reflects a fundamental and dangerous misunderstanding.
Misinformation is not something that can be overcome solely by spelling out facts just the right way. Defeating it requires earning and keeping the public’s trust.
During Fauci’s testimony this past week, Rep. Kweisi Mfume, D-Md., brought up the Tuskegee experiment, in which Black men with syphilis were denied treatment so doctors could study how the disease progressed.
Ironically, he claimed that they were deliberately injected with syphilis, which is false, and a conspiracy theory. But that fact check is irrelevant to the main question: Can vulnerable populations trust that the medical establishment will inform and protect them?
During the pandemic, research showed that many African Americans were reluctant to get vaccines, but it wasn’t because they were all COVID denialists. Many were continuing to take precautions such as wearing masks and avoiding crowds. They just didn’t trust that scientists had leveled with the public about the risks of vaccination.
They needed to tell the truth
When I visited London in 2021, I was amazed that people didn’t generally know which vaccine they had taken or when they would get their booster. They answered my question with a shrug and said they would just go whenever they were told they had an appointment.
They, too, had a polarizing, Donald Trump-like leader and the usual swirl of social media conspiracies. But they rolled up their sleeves when the National Health Service called because it was cashing in the trust it had built over decades.
Trust, not information, was the key. But just when it was needed most, some of the officials in charge of our COVID response undermined it. And as Rep. Deborah Ross, D-N.C., said during the hearings, “When people don’t trust scientists, they don’t trust the science.”
Studies have shown that once people lose trust in institutions, they become more open to conspiracy theories — not just about whatever specific topic might be in dispute but across the board.
Opportunists and “do your own research” chaos agents will take advantage of these lapses for a long time to come, fueling conspiracy theories and bad ideas of every stripe. The newest one I’ve heard is that COVID is ravaging people’s immune systems on a mass scale comparable to that of HIV. On what authority can such a falsehood now be debunked?
The truth works best
As the expression goes, trust is built in drops and lost in buckets, and this bucket is going to take a very long time to refill.
I hope the pandemic has proved that paternalistic, infantilizing messaging backfires. Transparency and accountability work.
In the four-plus years since COVID emerged, millions of people died, but so did something harder to quantify: the trust of a great many people in the science of public health. The authorities will have to live with the consequences, and so, unfortunately, will all the rest of us.
Zeynep Tufekci, Craig Newmark Professor of Journalism at Columbia School of Journalism, is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Unseen miracles keep us safe in the air.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.