In the first “Star Wars,” the he­roes find them­selves in a gar­bage com­pac­tor, fran­ti­cally grab­bing for any­thing that can keep them from get­ting crushed as the walls in­ex­o­ra­bly close in.

Such is the plight of civil so­ci­ety in coun­tries fac­ing what de­moc­racy ex­perts call “clos­ing space” — like the United States.

Open space clos­ing in

Fif­teen years ago, Rus­sia, Ethi­o­pia, and other semi-au­thor­i­tar­ian re­gimes be­gan re­strict­ing for­eign fund­ing to their non­profit sec­tors and paint­ing their ideas as for­eign or in­sin­u­at­ing that their lead­ers were cor­rupt. Reg­is­tra­tion laws were crafted that made per­fect com­pli­ance im­pos­sible.

This in­di­rect sub­ver­sion of civil so­ci­ety spread glob­ally, in­clud­ing within de­moc­ra­cies. In­dia closed 10,000 non­prof­its in 2015 for mi­nor ad­min­is­tra­tive is­sues. Poland raided women’s and gay-rights groups and seized com­put­ers af­ter large anti-gov­ern­ment pro­tests.

Advertise with us

Only groups that re­fused to back the rul­ing party’s line faced ret­ri­bu­tion. Ac­tiv­ists, at first, were not whisked off to jail. In­stead, they were weighed down with le­gal cases, fines, in­ves­ti­ga­tions, and the like un­til lead­ers burned out and funders dis­tanced them­selves from con­tro­versy.

To­day, the space in which U.S. civil so­ci­ety op­er­ates is clos­ing in — thanks to po­lar­iza­tion, not a rul­ing party. Il­lib­er­als on the far right and far left have de­cided that it’s not enough to per­suade.

They must elim­i­nate un­de­sir­able ideas — and or­ga­ni­za­tions — us­ing what­ever power is at hand, their tac­tics pulled straight from those used by anti-demo­cratic re­gimes abroad.

States have passed 38 new anti-pro­test laws. Free speech is be­ing throt­tled by uni­ver­sities fir­ing ten­ured pro­fes­sors for their words and by gag-or­der bills in­tro­duced in 36 states such as Flor­ida. Busi­nesses have faced state re­tal­i­a­tion for of­fer­ing cus­tom­ers de­sired prod­ucts such as in­vest­ment funds that em­ploy en­vi­ron­men­tal, so­cial, and gov­er­nance (ESG) screen­ing.

U.S. House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tive com­mit­tees have in­ves­ti­gated main­stream en­vi­ron­men­tal groups for fail­ing to reg­is­ter un­der the For­eign Agents Reg­is­tra­tion Act. Fifty-year-old church min­is­tries are sud­denly fac­ing state law­suits.

Advertise with us

Elim­i­nated mid­dle ground

When I looked for ex­am­ples of “clos­ing space,” I ended up with six pages. Since il­lib­er­als on the right wield more po­lit­i­cal power than those on the left, they are more likely to use gov­ern­men­tal reg­u­la­tory, le­gal, and over­sight agen­cies to si­lence their crit­ics.

Il­lib­er­als on the left ex­er­cise more power in uni­ver­sities, schools and cul­tural in­sti­tu­tions; they are largely work­ing through pri­vate reg­u­la­tion of speech and fund­ing. Un­pros­e­cuted vi­o­lence also plays a role in shut­ting down the civic sphere. Threats and vi­o­lence are al­ready ter­ri­fy­ing many non­prof­its, voter-reg­is­tra­tion ef­forts,and re­li­gious in­sti­tu­tions.

Il­lib­er­als of­ten tar­get the other side of the po­lit­i­cal spec­trum, of course: The il­lib­eral right is ha­rass­ing en­vi­ron­men­tal groups and or­ga­ni­za­tions pur­su­ing LGBTQ+ rights, among oth­ers. The il­lib­eral left has made con­ser­va­tives an en­dan­gered spe­cies on col­lege cam­puses. But both also ob­struct the work of the lib­er­als on their side of the par­ti­san di­vide.

In fact, clas­si­cal lib­er­als on the right were the first to feel the full force of the il­lib­eral right’s power. Pow­er­ful pub­lic lead­ers whose ideas may be quite con­ser­va­tive but who be­lieve in the free ex­change of ideas were caught un­pre­pared.

Pas­tors like Rus­sell Moore were forced out. Mag­a­zines like the Weekly Stan­dard were de­funded. In­tel­lec­tu­als such as David French faced un­re­lent­ing, ugly, vi­o­lent threats di­rected at them­selves, their chil­dren, and their fam­i­lies.

Advertise with us

Why tar­get one’s own side? By clos­ing space, il­lib­er­als elim­i­nate the mid­dle ground and re­duce com­pe­ti­tion for their ex­treme views. That ex­pands their power as peo­ple grudg­ingly ac­cept more anti-demo­cratic ac­tion from their own side, be­liev­ing it is nec­es­sary to pre­vent sim­i­lar ac­tions by their op­po­nents.

U.S. phi­lan­thro­pists are ad­dress­ing the prob­lem qui­etly and in piece­meal fash­ion, with as lit­tle at­ten­tion as pos­si­ble. Over­seas, such a lim­ited re­sponse failed. More or­ga­ni­za­tions faced re­stric­tions. Phi­lan­thropy it­self was tar­geted.

Re­call our own his­tory. Space for civil so­ci­ety was con­stricted dur­ing the Jim Crow South.

In Birming­ham, Ala., a Junior League could op­er­ate — but an in­ter­ra­cial league for check­ers play­ers couldn’t. In Mis­sis­sippi, there was a free press, but it was il­le­gal to pub­lish any­thing sup­port­ing so­cial equal­ity be­tween whites and Blacks. Groups pro­mot­ing dis­ap­proved ideas might have their pri­vate in­sur­ance de­nied, be closed for reg­u­la­tory vi­o­la­tions, or face vig­i­lante vi­o­lence that would go un­pun­ished.

De­fend de­moc­racy here

Over­seas, af­ter a de­cade, phi­lan­thro­pists learned to band to­gether. They sup­ported law­yers, cri­sis com­mu­ni­ca­tions, and cre­ated phys­i­cal and cy­ber se­cu­rity pro­grams. Pro­grams be­gan to whisk ac­tiv­ists to safety if dan­ger arose.

Advertise with us

Luck­ily, we are at the early stages of clos­ing space in the United States. And groups like the De­moc­racy Funders Net­work are learn­ing from over­seas to help non­prof­its and phi­lan­thro­pies across the po­lit­i­cal spec­trum find solu­tions.

Lib­er­als — whether con­ser­va­tive or pro­gres­sive — should join the ef­fort to pro­tect the na­tional trea­sure that is Amer­ica’s vi­brant civil so­ci­ety.

Kleinfeld is a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. This is drawn from her latest paper, “ Closing Civic Space in the United States.”