Future his­to­ri­ans will look back on our era as a case study in the abuse of po­lit­i­cal lan­guage — to drive so­cial me­dia likes and fol­lows, to de­lib­er­ately of­fend and in turn to claim of­fense, to ques­tion mo­tives of the op­pos­ing party, to pit peo­ple against each other, or to do all of the above si­mul­ta­ne­ously.

One of the par­tic­u­larly per­ni­cious as­pects of how we use po­lit­i­cal lan­guage is the ten­dency of po­lit­i­cal play­ers to talk past one an­other. Words like “pa­tri­o­tism,” “de­moc­racy” and “eq­uity” are freighted with con­tro­versy — some­times with good rea­son, but most of the time as a way to bol­ster one’s own po­lit­i­cal po­si­tion.

Words like these be­come mas­sive stum­bling blocks for real con­ver­sa­tion about real is­sues.

Promis­ing speech

For­tu­nately, a net­work of civic-minded do­nors and char­i­ta­ble or­ga­ni­za­tions called Phi­lan­thropy for Ac­tive Civic En­gage­ment just re­leased new num­bers from its on­go­ing Civic Lan­guage Per­cep­tions Proj­ect — a sur­vey aimed at dis­cov­er­ing how civic lan­guage unites, di­vides and mo­ti­vates Amer­i­can vot­ers. It in­cludes a di­verse cross-sec­tion of Amer­i­cans across the po­lit­i­cal spec­trum.

Advertise with us

The re­sults seem prom­is­ing. They show that Amer­i­cans across the po­lit­i­cal spec­trum still hold on to a com­mon vo­cab­u­lary for our civic life.

PACE’s sur­vey found that Amer­i­cans are mostly pos­i­tive about what they called “civic terms.” Ideas such as “free­dom,” “com­mu­nity,” “ser­vice” and “Con­sti­tu­tion” still res­o­nate with the vast ma­jor­ity of re­spon­dents. Com­pared to the pre­vi­ous sur­vey re­sults from 2021, the lat­est find­ings show sig­nifi­cant gains in pos­i­tiv­ity for words like “lib­erty,” “cit­i­zen” and “be­long­ing.”

The sur­vey also shows us where we might adapt our vo­cab­u­lary so as to re­con­nect with our fel­low cit­i­zens rather than speak­ing past them. The PACE sur­vey found that cer­tain terms — “equal­ity” and “be­long­ing,” for in­stance — are bet­ter re­ceived than phrases like “so­cial justice” or “ra­cial eq­uity.”

“De­moc­racy” is a more pop­u­lar term than “re­pub­lic.” “Un­ity” turns out to be a much more lik­able term than “bridg­ing” or “bi­par­ti­san.”

Pop­u­lar speech

There are, of course, lim­its to this kind of sur­vey. The most pop­u­lar word sur­veyed was “free­dom,” reg­is­ter­ing around 85% pos­i­tiv­ity.

Advertise with us

Yet free­dom has many dif­fer­ent ap­pli­ca­tions and con­texts, rang­ing from “re­pro­duc­tive free­dom” to “re­li­gious free­dom.” Words can mean dif­fer­ent things to dif­fer­ent peo­ple, and this will ever be so in a large and plu­ral­is­tic so­ci­ety.

Be that as it may, we ought at least to fig­ure out a shared un­der­stand­ing of the terms for our deal­ings with each other as fel­low cit­i­zens. Civic ed­u­ca­tion can fill a large part of this func­tion, mak­ing us aware of the foun­da­tional doc­u­ments, ide­als and his­tor­i­cal mem­ory we share and teach­ing us meth­ods for dis­agree­ing re­spect­fully.

Civic for­ma­tion of this sort will re­quire long-term in­vest­ments in a cat­e­gory of ed­u­ca­tion that has been badly ne­glected for far too long. Its res­tora­tion is mis­sion es­sen­tial to de­moc­racy.

Chang­ing speech

For now, PACE de­serves credit for dig­ging into the data to learn about how Amer­i­cans think and speak. As we ap­proach the 250th an­ni­ver­sary of Amer­ica’s birth, and what prom­ises to be a heated elec­tion year, we can each do our part to speak a civic lan­guage that builds up rather than tears down.

As George Or­well once wrote of the cor­rupted po­lit­i­cal lan­guage of his day, “One can­not change this all in a mo­ment, but one can at least change one’s own hab­its.”

Hans Zeiger is president of the Jack Miller Center, a nationwide network of scholars and teachers committed to advancing the core texts and ideas of the American political tradition.