For many years, Ohio has been thought of as a bell­wether state: With rare ex­cep­tions, who­ever won Ohio in a pres­i­den­tial elec­tion won the na­tion as a whole. But in 2020, Don­ald Trump won Ohio by about 8 points even as Joe Biden led the na­tional pop­u­lar vote by more than 4 points and, of course, won the Elec­toral Col­lege vote.

Then Ohio’s 2022 Senate elec­tion was won by J.D. Vance, who has staked out a hard-line ide­o­log­i­cal po­si­tion that may be more thor­oughly MAGA than that of Trump him­self. And in last week’s Re­pub­li­can Senate pri­mary, Trump’s en­dorse­ment was enough to pro­pel Ber­nie Moreno, a for­mer car dealer who has never held elected of­fice, to vic­tory over the pre­ferred can­di­dates of the state’s rel­a­tively mod­er­ate Re­pub­li­can es­tab­lish­ment.

So I’ve been try­ing to un­der­stand what hap­pened to Ohio, and what it can teach us about Amer­ica’s fu­ture. My short an­swer is that the United States of Amer­ica has be­come the Dis­con­nected States of Amer­ica, on sev­eral lev­els.

Disconnected States

Advertise with us

Once upon a time, Ohio’s bell­wether sta­tus could be ex­plained by the fact that in some sense it looked like Amer­ica. These days, no state re­ally looks like Amer­ica be­cause the eco­nomic for­tunes of dif­fer­ent re­gions have di­verged so dras­ti­cally.

Ohio has found it­self on the los­ing side of that di­ver­gence. You might ex­pect Ohio vot­ers to sup­port pol­i­ti­cians whose pol­i­cies would help re­verse this rel­a­tive de­cline.

But there’s a strik­ing dis­con­nect be­tween who vot­ers, es­pe­cially work­ing-class white vot­ers, per­ceive as be­ing on their side and pol­i­ti­cians’ ac­tual pol­i­cies. For that mat­ter, there’s a strik­ing dis­con­nect be­tween vot­ers’ views of what is hap­pen­ing with the econ­omy and their per­sonal ex­pe­ri­ences. It’s vibes all the way down.

OK, some facts.

Com­pare per ca­pita in­come in Ohio with in­come in a rel­a­tively rich state such as Mas­sa­chu­setts. Dur­ing the gen­er­a­tion-long boom that fol­lowed World War II, the two were ba­si­cally tied. Since around 1980, how­ever, Ohio has been on a long rel­a­tive slide. Its in­come is now about a third less than that of Mas­sa­chu­setts.

Advertise with us

A lot of this has to do with the loss of well-paid man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs. There are con­sid­er­ably fewer man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs in Ohio than there used to be, partly be­cause of for­eign com­pe­ti­tion, in­clud­ing the fa­mous “China shock” — the surge of Chi­nese im­ports be­tween the late 1990s and around 2010 that re­sulted in man­u­fac­tur­ing job losses — al­though dein­dus­tri­al­iza­tion has been hap­pen­ing al­most ev­ery­where, even in Ger­many, which runs huge trade sur­pluses.

And wages for pro­duc­tion work­ers in Ohio have lagged be­hind in­fla­tion for 20 years. That prob­a­bly has a lot to do with the col­lapse of unions, which used to rep­resent a quar­ter of Ohio’s pri­vate-sec­tor work­ers, but are van­ish­ing from the scene.

More broadly, the 21st-cen­tury econ­omy has fa­vored met­ro­pol­i­tan ar­eas with highly ed­u­cated work­forces. Ohio, with its rel­a­tively low share of col­lege-ed­u­cated adults, has been left be­hind.

Disgruntled voters

So it makes sense for Ohio vot­ers to feel dis­grun­tled. But again, you might have ex­pected dis­grun­tled vot­ers to sup­port pol­i­ti­cians ac­tu­ally try­ing to ad­dress the state’s prob­lems.

Advertise with us

The Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion cer­tainly hoped that its in­dus­trial pol­i­cies, which have led to a surge in man­u­fac­tur­ing in­vest­ment, would win over more blue-col­lar vot­ers. You might also have ex­pected Dem­o­crats to get some div­i­dend from the fact that un­em­ploy­ment in Ohio is now sig­nifi­cantly lower than it was un­der Trump, even be­fore the COVID-19 pan­demic struck. But that doesn’t seem to have hap­pened.

What about Trump? In most ways he gov­erned as a con­ven­tional right-wing Re­pub­li­can, among other things try­ing to re­verse the suc­cess of Obam­ac­are, which had greatly re­duced the per­cent­age of Ohio­ans with­out health in­sur­ance. Trump did, how­ever, break with party or­tho­doxy by launch­ing a trade war, with sub­stan­tial tar­iffs on some man­u­fac­tured im­ports.

In eco­nomic terms, the trade war failed. A new pa­per, whose au­thors in­clude the au­thors of the orig­i­nal China shock anal­y­sis, con­firms the re­sults of other stud­ies find­ing that the Trump tar­iffs didn’t raise man­u­fac­tur­ing em­ploy­ment. The au­thors go fur­ther by break­ing down the re­gional ef­fects and find spe­cif­i­cally that the trade war “has not pro­vided eco­nomic help to the U.S. heart­land.”

Yet, they found, the trade war ap­pears to have been a po­lit­i­cal suc­cess. Re­gions whose in­dus­tries were pro­tected by tar­iffs be­came more likely to vote for Trump and Re­pub­li­cans in gen­eral, even though the tar­iffs didn’t re­sult in a boost to em­ploy­ment. This, the au­thors note, is “con­sis­tent with ex­pres­sive views of pol­i­tics.”

Dis­turbing views

That is, in 2020, many work­ing-class vot­ers in Ohio and else­where saw Trump as be­ing on their side even though his pol­i­cies didn’t help them. And if you look at some of to­day’s poll­ing, it ap­pears that they refuse to give Biden credit for pol­i­cies that ac­tu­ally do help work­ers.

Advertise with us

I’m not mak­ing a pre­dic­tion for No­vem­ber. Per­cep­tions of the econ­omy have im­proved, even if they’re still some­what de­pressed. So the econ­omy may be good enough for other is­sues, in­clud­ing re­pro­duc­tive rights, to carry Biden over the top.

But it’s still dis­turb­ing to see just how dis­con­nected views about pol­i­ti­cians have be­come from what those pol­i­ti­cians re­ally do.

Paul Krugman is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Prices aren't going up very much even if you feel they are.”