I’m not an Ohio voter so my interest in the newly elected senator J.D. Vance is more literary than political. I first heard of him when his book “Hillbilly Elegy” came out. I loved the book because it was beautifully written. The author was a 32 year old who had already seen enough of life to write a memoir.
It’s an autobiographical account by a very young man who survived some horrendous episodes in his early life that he describes in a calm, matter-of-fact manner. He survives the chaos in large part because of the aggressive devotion of his grandparents. He is recruited into the army where his career goes very well. Clearly very intelligent, he goes to college on the GI Bill, graduates early summa cum laude, then goes to a prestigious law school.
It was very educational and contemporary. I had never before read a first-person account of life in rural Appalachia, with such clear insights into what he describes as a culture of poverty, particularly among poor white families. He starts the book by using Reagan’s term “welfare queens” to describe some of the women who raised him. He describes his mother’s struggles with drug abuse, and the fiercely protective love of his grandparents.
Several episodes in the book have stayed with me.
There is a touching one where his grandfather secretly wires a telephone into his toy box so he can call his grandparents for help if needed.
There is another in which they go into town and his grandparents drop him off at the toy store while they run an errand. The store does not allow unaccompanied children inside, so the manager asks him to wait outside. The grandfather comes back and trashes the store to retaliate against the manager for disrespecting his grandson.
Read More
In another, his grandmother points a gun at the military recruiter and threatens him with dire consequences should any harm befall JD in the service.
The book makes it clear that Vance views his grandparents’ behavior in the above instances as acceptable because they are motivated by love of family. I wondered if that was quite the right lesson for a child or adolescent to learn.
One piece of the book that stayed with me is how JD finds the regimentation of military life to be a haven compared with the way he grew up. This was his cot in which he would sleep every night, that was his locker where he would store his belongings every day and they would all still be there tomorrow. The predictable routine and the clear expectations were new and comforting.
Fast forward to graduate school where he has fallen in love with the woman he later married. They have an argument and he bolts. She goes after him and finds him sitting on some steps — maybe the library steps — in tears.
It turns out he does not know how to resolve an argument without resorting anger or violence. This was not something that was ever modeled for him. Later, he goes to her family’s home for Thanksgiving and marvels at how her family argue without coming to blows.
What did I not love about the book? Mostly the naivete, which was forgivable, given his youth. Here was a man who grew up in a family that often relied on public assistance. He attends a public school, then joins the military, where he continues to be supported by the taxpayer, and then to college on the GI Bill.
Yet, he concludes that he succeeded purely out of luck and the love of his family. The moral of his story is that the government should stay out of people’s lives.
I heard later that his star quality had not been lost on the political community and that John Boehner had already tapped him to run for office from Ohio. He evidently resisted at that point, and went on instead to become a venture capitalist. He earned some respect in some quarters — and anger in others — when he became a Never-Trumper.
The next thing I heard was that he was running as the Trump-endorsed Republican candidate for the US Senate from the state of Ohio. And now he has won that election and will soon become part of “government.”
So I look forward to reading Volume 2 of “Hillbilly Elegy” — maybe “Hillbilly Venture Capitalist,” with Volume 3, “Senator Hillbilly,” to follow. Perhaps we will learn what forces brought about these changes of heart. I did hear a speech in which he said he would never forget where he came from. He sounded as humble and grateful as he did in 2016. But evidently he never understood he had been supported by the taxpayer.
I wish him well and hope he does well by the people of Ohio. Including those who, like himself, may sometimes need help from society.
Mary Ganguli is professor of psychiatry, neurology, and epidemiology at the University of Pittsburgh. Her previous article was “How to improve the relationship between public health and the public” written with Hugh C. Hendrie.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.