On Christ and car­bon­aceous chon­drites, Cyril P. Opeil is a uni­ver­sal au­thor­ity. A Cath­o­lic priest and a phys­i­cist, the Penn­syl­va­nia na­tive is a ser­vant of faith and sci­ence sift­ing the mys­ter­ies of cre­ation.

“There shouldn’t be any op­po­si­tion, in terms of faith, to look­ing at sci­ence for an­swers,” said the Je­suit priest in a phone in­ter­view this week.

Causes for won­der

“Some of the an­swers that sci­ence is go­ing to pro­vide have very lit­tle to do with faith. But some of them cre­ate causes to won­der, to ask deeper ques­tions about the beauty of the uni­verse and the beauty of what we have here in cre­ation.”

Advertise with us

Opeil was at the Univer­sity of Ari­zona as part of a team that will an­a­lyze sam­ples col­lected from the as­ter­oid Bennu. The rocks and dust may yield clues about the be­gin­ning of life on Earth, or the Creation, de­pend­ing on your per­spec­tive.

The as­ter­oid was dis­cov­ered on Sept. 11, 1999 (cue the con­spir­acy kooks) and named through a na­tional con­test by a third-grader in North Car­o­lina who saw sim­i­lar­i­ties be­tween the shape of the space­craft and Bennu, a myth­o­log­i­cal bird an­cient Egyp­tians wor­shipped as the Cre­ator.

“We’re in the midst of cre­ation, whether we ac­knowl­edge it or not,” he said. “And we can look at cre­ation the way we look at a paint­ing. The bet­ter the paint­ing, whether it’s a Car­a­vag­gio or Pi­c­asso or who­ever, we can see the hand be­hind the paint­ing.”

It’s right there in the brush­strokes.

Opeil was or­dained in 1994 and be­gan study­ing phys­ics two years later. He earned a Ph.D. in 2004 and found post-doc­tor­ate work at the Los Ala­mos Na­tional Lab­o­ra­tory. He joined the fac­ulty of Boston Col­lege in 2006.

Advertise with us

Another earth some­where

He was there two years. “I worked on a num­ber of kinds of proj­ects — mostly what’s called ‘pho­to­emis­sion,’ where you look at ma­teri­als and you shine light on them. And then you find out what kind of elec­tron struc­ture these ma­teri­als have.”

Which brings us to car­bon­aceous chon­drites. “It’s ba­si­cally a type of ex­tra­ter­res­trial clay,” he ex­plained. “What’s fas­ci­nat­ing about car­bon­aceous chon­drites is if they are clay, there had to be an­other place in our uni­verse that had liq­uid wa­ter for a very long time, not on the earth.”

That means that “some­where in our so­lar sys­tem, we had an­other planet or plan­e­toid, which was very much like Earth and had liq­uid wa­ter ... for a very long time in or­der to cre­ate clay, which hap­pens over hun­dreds of thou­sands of years.”

While the Vat­i­can got it wrong with Ga­li­leo, Father Opeil pointed out that the Cath­o­lic Church — par­tic­u­larly Je­suits — em­braced sci­ence cen­tu­ries ago. The Vat­i­can op­er­ates a pair of world-class ob­ser­va­to­ries in Ari­zona and out­side Rome. The Roman ob­ser­va­tory is Father Opeil’s next stop.

Advertise with us

Two do­mains

Christ or car­bon­aceous chon­drites? Opeil doesn’t see a need to choose. “There are some ques­tions about faith that per­tain to the Bible and per­tain to hu­man re­la­tion­ships and our re­la­tion­ship to God that are not di­rectly in­formed by sci­ence,” he said.

“So there are dif­fer­ent do­mains here (sci­ence and faith), but both are about hu­man ex­pe­ri­ence and help­ing us un­der­stand this ex­pe­ri­ence. Whether it be sci­ence or re­li­gion, how do we in­te­grate this into our lives and our own sense of re­la­tion­ships, and our past, and per­haps our fu­ture as well?”

Spo­ken like a man of faith and sci­ence, shin­ing a light on the brush­strokes.

Chris Kelly is a col­um­nist for the Scran­ton Times-Tri­bune.