Technically speaking, Donald Trump is still far from winning the Republican presidential nomination, but his victory Tuesday in the New Hampshire primary was enough to push the Republican National Committee off the sidelines and into his corner.

“I do think there is a message that is coming out from the voters which is very clear. We need to unite around our eventual nominee, which is going to be Donald Trump, and we need to beat Joe Biden,” Ronna McDaniel, the RNC chair, said in a recent interview on Fox News.

Other high-pro­file Re­pub­li­cans have fol­lowed suit, but at least one Re­pub­li­can has sounded a sour note about the pros­pect of an­other can­di­dacy for Trump.

The sour note

Advertise with us

“When I have peo­ple come up to me who voted for Rea­gan in ’76 and have been con­ser­va­tive their whole life say that they don’t want to vote for Trump again, that’s a prob­lem,” said Gov. Ron DeSan­tis of Flor­ida, who re­cently left the race for pres­i­dent, and who also en­dorsed Trump.

“So he’s got to fig­ure out a way to solve that. I think there’s an en­thu­si­asm prob­lem over­all, and then I also just think there are some vot­ers that have checked out at this point that you got to find a way to get them back.”

DeSan­tis is right. He also un­der­states the prob­lem for the for­mer pres­i­dent, whose vic­tory in the New Hamp­shire pri­mary rests on shak­ier ground than might ap­pear at first glance.

Trump, pre­dict­ably, dom­i­nated among Re­pub­li­cans, the bulk of the elec­tor­ate Tues­day. But among the 44% of pri­mary vot­ers who iden­ti­fied as in­de­pen­dents, he lost, by 58% to 39%. Among the 28% of pri­mary vot­ers who iden­ti­fied as mod­er­ate, he lost, by 72% to 25%. And among the 48% of vot­ers who had a col­lege ed­u­ca­tion or higher, he lost, by about 56% to 42%.

There are other signs of trou­ble: 38% of vot­ers in the New Hamp­shire Re­pub­li­can pri­mary said they would be dis­sat­is­fied if Trump won the nom­i­na­tion, and 42% of vot­ers said that if Trump were con­victed of a crime, he would not be fit for the pres­i­dency.

Advertise with us

It’s easy to dis­miss all this as the in­ev­i­ta­ble re­sult of a pri­mary in which Demo­cratic and in­de­pen­dent vot­ers can cast a bal­lot. But most of the peo­ple who went to the polls this week were reg­is­tered Re­pub­li­cans. They were not doc­tri­naire lib­er­als or “re­sis­tance” Dem­o­crats. They were swing vot­ers who will de­ter­mine the No­vem­ber elec­tion in New Hamp­shire and else­where.

A weak in­cum­bent

Trump is run­ning, es­sen­tially, as an in­cum­bent. And the re­sults in New Hamp­shire are ev­i­dence that, com­pared with a typ­i­cal in­cum­bent pres­i­dent run­ning for re­elec­tion, he is weak.

It does not work as a di­rect com­par­i­son, but it is still in­struc­tive to look at the 1992 Re­pub­li­can pres­i­den­tial pri­mary. George H.W. Bush, the in­cum­bent, fended off a pop­u­list chal­lenge from Pat Buchanan, a long­time Re­pub­li­can op­er­a­tive, con­ser­va­tive com­men­tator and har­bin­ger, in many ways, of the rise of Trump and Trump­ism.

Bush won the New Hamp­shire pri­mary, 53% to 38%. But most com­men­tators framed Bush’s vic­tory as a nearly cat­a­strophic fail­ure. Why? Be­cause Buchanan’s strong show­ing un­der­scored the pres­i­dent’s weak­ness with the most con­ser­va­tive Re­pub­li­cans, to say noth­ing of the coun­try at large.

Advertise with us

You can see the lim­its of the com­par­i­son in the fact that Trump ex­cels with the most con­ser­va­tive Re­pub­li­cans. But this might mean, in the con­text of a gen­eral elec­tion, that he is on the wrong side of the di­vide within his party, es­pe­cially if Ha­ley stays in the race through South Car­o­lina and con­tin­ues to pull in­de­pen­dents and more mod­er­ate Re­pub­li­cans into her cor­ner.

Bur­dened by a di­vided party and the lin­ger­ing pain of a sharp re­ces­sion in 1992 — un­em­ploy­ment peaked at 7.8% that June — Bush lost his re­elec­tion bid to a young up­start from Ar­kan­sas, Bill Clin­ton.

Biden has prob­lems, too

With a tight la­bor mar­ket and ris­ing wages, es­pe­cially for those at the low­est part of the scale, Pres­i­dent Joe Biden has the ad­van­tage of a much stron­ger econ­omy than Bush did. He is also, how­ever, pre­sid­ing over a di­vided party, whose young­est vot­ers in par­tic­u­lar are deeply dis­sat­is­fied with the state of the coun­try.

As he shifts gears to his cam­paign, Biden has se­ri­ous prob­lems. But lost in all of the fo­cus on the cur­rent pres­i­dent is the fact that the for­mer pres­i­dent is in an even worse po­si­tion. Be­set by le­gal trou­ble, fac­ing sev­eral crim­i­nal counts and con­sumed with re­sent­ment, rage and dreams of ret­ri­bu­tion, Trump has done noth­ing to ex­pand be­yond the co­a­li­tion he as­sem­bled to try to win the pre­vi­ous elec­tion.

Advertise with us

Of course, no one in an elec­tion cam­paign has to be truly pop­u­lar. He (or she) just has to be more pop­u­lar than the other per­son on the bal­lot. And at this stage, it is dif­fi­cult to say who will clear that hur­dle.

Either way, there is a case to make that Dem­o­crats are tak­ing a risk by nom­i­nat­ing Biden for a sec­ond term. But there is an even stron­ger case to make that Re­pub­li­cans are tak­ing a cat­a­strophic risk by nom­i­nat­ing Trump for a third time.

Jamelle Bouie is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “The real difference between Republicans and Democrats.”