There can be few American public institutions more widely detested than the National Collegiate Athletic Association. The NCAA spent decades promoting the ideal of the amateur “student-athlete,” barring football and basketball players from compensation while their coaches and university athletic directors collected millions of dollars a year.

Now, the NCAA implies a lawsuit demanding compensation for the use of college players’ “names, images and likenesses” (NIL) could be an extinction event for the collegiate sports system.

Asking for $1.4 billion

The athletes who brought the case have asked for $1.4 billion in damages, which under antitrust law would be trebled if they win, for a total of $4.2 billion. A judgment of that magnitude, the NCAA says in an appeal, “would necessitate curtailing college sports programs across the country.”

Advertise with us

This problem is the product of the transformation of college football and basketball into big businesses so rich and powerful that they often overwhelm the academic goals of their universities.

Who’s responsible? The NCAA and the universities with big-money programs themselves. They built these enormous financial edifices on a business model based on the players’ free labor. Now the NCAA and the richest athletic programs are feeling the pain from the collapse of their franchise.

The numbers tell the story. In recent years the Big Ten, Southeastern and Big 12 conferences signed multiyear television deals for football worth a total of more than $12 billion. In 2016, the NCAA renewed its contract with Turner Sports and CBS for broadcast rights to its men’s basketball tournament for $8.8 billion over eight years.

The plaintiffs assert that more than 150 football and basketball coaches in the NCAA’s elite Division I earn more than $1 million a year; the best-paid 25 football coaches collect an average of $5.2 million and the top 25 basketball coaches an average of $3.2 million.

The opening of the NIL spigot has provided a bounty for star college football and basketball athletes. Seven-figure NIL endorsement deals have been signed by marquee players, topped by USC basketball player Bronny James, the son of Lakers star LeBron James, for $5.9 million from Nike and Apple’s Beats by Dre, among other brands, and University of Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders, the son of former NFL star and current Colorado coach Deion Sanders, for $4.5 million from brands including Adidas and Gatorade.

Advertise with us

In 2021, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the NCAA was subject to antitrust laws and that its restrictions on certain education-related benefits for athletes breached the laws. In a concurring opinion, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that “Nowhere else in America can businesses get away with agreeing not to pay their workers a fair market rate on the theory that their product is defined by not paying their workers a fair market rate.”

Employees, not student athletes

The following September, the National Labor Relations Board defined scholarship athletes at academic institutions as employees.

The term “student-athletes” had been coined chiefly “to avoid paying workers’ compensation claims to injured athletes.”

This May, the NLRB’s Los Angeles office followed Abruzzo’s lead by filing a complaint against USC, the Pac-12 Conference and the NCAA, alleging that they broke the law by misclassifying college athletes in men’s and women’s basketball and football as student-athletes rather than employees. The case is pending.

Advertise with us

The NCAA is trying to hold back the tide on two fronts. In its appeal of Wilken’s latest ruling, it is arguing that the judge was wrong to certify the three classes of plaintiffs. College players don’t have the common characteristics needed for a class action, the NCAA asserts; nor would it be fair to apportion, say, revenues from a TV deal evenly among all players on a team.

“The value of NIL is inherently tied to each athlete’s unique status and characteristics,” it told the appeals court. “A star quarterback can plainly command more money for the use of his image on the cover of a video game than an unheard-of, backup offensive lineman.”

The NCAA has been trying to persuade Congress to overrule state laws in 30 states governing NIL payment rights. More tellingly, the group wants a law affirming that “student-athletes ... are not employees of an institution” — in other words, to overturn the NLRB’s doctrine in a way that would stifle most players’ earning rights and eliminate such threats as unionization.

The NCAA’s not special

“College sports are a uniquely powerful and beloved institution,” NCAA president Charlie Baker, told Congress. How often have we heard this before?

Advertise with us

It’s a rare industry that doesn’t come to Capitol Hill pleading that it’s so special that it deserves a tailor-made system of laws and regulations. Baker may claim that his industry is unique, but he sounds exactly like every other business leader looking for a legal bailout.

The NCAA is trapped in a morass of its own making. Its century-old business model has come face to face with 21st century realities, and it needs to deal with the world as it is, instead of trying to keep living in a world of its own.

Michael Hiltzik is a columnist for the Los Angeles Times.