On Sunday, a New York Times/Siena College poll showed President Joe Biden behind Donald Trump in a bunch of battleground states. Then Tuesday, voters handed Democrats a string of election victories.
Are the polls wrong? Are the Democrats strong but Biden weak? Let me offer a few thoughts.
Dissatisfied but practical
Americans increasingly use polls to vent, not to vote. During the 20th century, presidents generally had high approval ratings. Since 2005, sitting presidents have had underwater approval ratings during about 77% of their terms.
As progressive political strategist Michael Podhorzer argues, a lot of this negativity is not a reflection on particular politicians. It is “indicative of broad and intense dissatisfaction with our governing institutions and political parties.” When pollsters call people, they take the opportunity to lash out at whoever is in the White House. It’s their way of venting and saying they want change.
This does not mean that when it comes time to cast ballots and actually pick a president, their preferences will be the same. “Americans know the difference between answering a survey and casting a ballot, even if the polling industrial complex and pundits don’t,” Podhorzer writes.
Podhorzer notes that since 2017, there have been significant anti-MAGA majorities pretty much every time voters went to the voting booths. There’s a good chance that that anti-MAGA majority will still be there in 2024. Biden doesn’t have to become magically popular; he just has to remind the tens of millions of Americans who voted against MAGA before why they need to vote against MAGA again.
The median voter rule still applies. Parties win when they stay close to the center of the electorate. Abortion was not always a great issue for Democrats, but this year, Democrats effectively played to median voters, with, for example, an ad in Ohio in which a father who grew up in the church castigated the GOP for not allowing abortion exceptions for rape and the health of the mother.
Voters want results
Dull but effective government can win, and circus politics is failing. The Trumpian GOP has built its political strategy around culture war theatrics — be they anti-trans or anti-woke. That culture war strategy may get you hits on right-wing media, but it has flopped for Ron DeSantis, flopped for Vivek Ramaswamy, and it flopped Tuesday night on the ballot.
Gov. Andy Beshear, a Democrat, did so well in Kentucky in part because he stayed close to the practicalities, focusing on boring old governance issues like jobs, health care costs and investment in infrastructure. He also demonstrated a Christian faith that was the opposite of Christian nationalism.
As he told E.J. Dionne Jr. of The Washington Post, “For me, faith is about uniting all people. It says all children are children of God. And if you’re truly living out your faith, you’re not playing into these anger and hatred games.”
Remember that none of us know what the political climate will be like a year from now. Neither you nor I have any clue how some set of swing voters in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin are going to see things in 12 months or what events will intervene in the meantime. Nobody does.
It’s better to ask the simple question: Do I think Biden is doing a good job? I look around and conclude that he is. The economic trends are good for average Americans. The U.S. economy grew at a torrid 4.9% annualized rate in the third quarter of this year, by far the highest cumulative, inflation-adjusted growth in the Group of 7. The prime age employment rate is near record highs, and inflation is down to 3.7%.
Household debt is way down. The average family’s net worth increased by an inflation-adjusted 37% between 2019 and 2022. The gains were broadly felt: Income increased almost across the board, benefiting urban and rural people, homeowners and renters, white people and Black people.
The mood is so glum, many voters don’t yet perceive these improvements, reeling as they are from the recent bout of inflation. Will they come to appreciate all the positive trends this time next year? I have no idea, and neither do you. It can take a long time for perceptions to catch up with economic realities. The only thing we can do is put our faith in the idea that good policy deserves our support.
A comparison election
Mitch Landrieu oversees Biden’s infrastructure initiative. Nearly $400 billion has gone into investments. “When history renders its verdict, this will be comparable to Works Progress Administration, or the Eisenhower highway construction program or rural electrification,” he said, adding “This is not a conservative or liberal thing.”
Biden has to make this a comparison election — him versus Trump. He has to make this a prosaic election. It’s not which of these two men do you dislike least; it’s which set of goods do you want to buy: low prescription drug prices or higher ones, some student debt forgiveness or none, abundant infrastructure jobs or few? If Biden can make this about concrete benefits to everyday Americans, I suspect he’ll be fine.
David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article originally appeared.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.