Pres­i­dent Joe Biden has been trav­el­ing the U.S. tout­ing a man­u­fac­tur­ing re­vival, but un­for­tu­nately, there is much less sub­stance to this “Biden Boom” than the White House would have Amer­i­cans be­lieve.

Even un­der the ros­i­est of pro­jec­tions, the ad­min­is­tra­tion’s sig­na­ture pro­grams will do lit­tle to in­crease man­u­fac­tur­ing em­ploy­ment. It will do even less to up­lift the over­all econ­omy.

Inevi­ta­ble ex­pan­sion

Con­struc­tion spend­ing on man­u­fac­tur­ing fa­cil­i­ties more than dou­bled from an an­nu­al­ized rate of $81 bil­lion this time last year to an all-time high of nearly $200 bil­lion in Au­gust. Some of that in­crease can be at­trib­uted to the in­cen­tives pro­vided by the In­fla­tion Re­duc­tion Act and the CHIPS Act, both cham­pi­oned by the pres­i­dent.

Advertise with us

But there are more rel­e­vant fac­tors. A near-term ex­pan­sion in do­mes­tic man­u­fac­tur­ing was all but in­ev­i­ta­ble.

Short­ages caused by COVID, back­logs at ma­jor ports in 2021 and a three-year-long (and con­tin­u­ing) surge in re­tail sales cre­ated a com­pel­ling case for reshor­ing pro­duc­tion even with­out those in­cen­tives. Spend­ing on con­sumer goods is 30% higher now than when the pan­demic started, and global sup­ply chains have yet to fully re­cover.

Another rea­son the re­cent run-up in man­u­fac­tur­ing in­vest­ment is not as im­pres­sive as it might seem: When ad­justed for in­fla­tion, the fig­ures are over­shad­owed by a de­cline in in­vest­ment in the rest of the econ­omy.

The U.S. Bureau of Eco­nomic Anal­y­sis es­ti­mates that in­fla­tion-ad­justed in­vest­ment in man­u­fac­tur­ing fa­cil­i­ties was a more mod­est $125 bil­lion (an­nu­al­ized) in the sec­ond quar­ter. Out­side of man­u­fac­tur­ing, in­vest­ment in non-res­i­den­tial struc­tures was $480 bil­lion last quar­ter, down $90 bil­lion from its peak in the third quar­ter of 2019 (again, fig­ures are an­nu­al­ized).

Long-term ef­fects

Advertise with us

The long-term ef­fects of Biden’s in­dus­trial pol­i­cies are even less im­pres­sive. An anal­y­sis con­ducted by the La­bor Energy Part­ner­ship, a strong sup­porter of Biden’s pol­i­cies, said they would cre­ate 150,000 ad­di­tional man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs by 2030.

That amounts to an in­crease of just 1.3% rel­a­tive to the 13.1 mil­lion work­ers in em­ployed in man­u­fac­tur­ing right now. By com­par­i­son, the U.S. econ­omy cre­ated 272,000 man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs in 2018 alone.

The ad­min­is­tra­tion hopes that by fun­nel­ing its re­sources to­ward semi­con­duc­tors and green en­ergy, it can fos­ter the growth of a man­u­fac­tur­ing eco­sys­tem that will en­sure U.S. lead­er­ship in high-tech man­u­fac­tur­ing. Re­search sug­gests oth­er­wise.

An­a­lysts at the World Trade Or­ga­ni­za­tion sum­ma­rize ev­i­dence this way: For econ­o­mies in tran­si­tion from un­de­vel­oped to de­vel­oped, di­rect in­vest­ment in man­u­fac­tur­ing can in­deed ben­e­fit do­mes­tic sup­pli­ers. For fully de­vel­oped econ­o­mies, how­ever, di­rect in­vest­ment has no ben­e­fits for ei­ther do­mes­tic sup­pli­ers or pur­chas­ers of man­u­fac­tur­ing prod­ucts.

That’s be­cause in­ves­tors are al­ready aware of what they have to of­fer, and cap­i­tal mar­kets — in the U.S. es­pe­cially — can eas­ily fi­nance the cre­ation of new in­dus­tries if there is a strong busi­ness case for them.

Advertise with us

In fact, the Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion’s ten­dency to in­clude in these pro­grams in­cen­tives fa­vor­able to unions and other pro­gres­sive in­ter­ests can ac­tu­ally make it more dif­fi­cult for in­ves­tors to as­cer­tain the full costs of ex­pand­ing pro­duc­tion in the U.S.

Then again, as Peter­son In­sti­tute Pres­i­dent Adam Posen points out, un­der a more busi­ness-friendly ad­min­is­tra­tion, the pol­icy’s in­cen­tive pro­grams would be ripe for cor­rup­tion.

No doubt sin­cere

The pres­i­dent is no doubt sin­cere in his de­sire to re­vive U.S. man­u­fac­tur­ing, and it’s tempt­ing to look at the surge in reshor­ing as ev­i­dence that his ad­min­is­tra­tion’s pol­i­cies are hav­ing a trans­for­ma­tive ef­fect. Yet even the most op­ti­mis­tic pro­jec­tions sug­gest that Biden’s in­dus­trial pol­icy will have only a mi­nor ef­fect on U.S. man­u­fac­tur­ing em­ploy­ment.

Karl W. Smith is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “The government was wrong to be so gloomy about the economy.”