In 2021, al­most two-thirds of in­ves­tors said they con­sid­ered en­vi­ron­men­tal, so­cial and gov­er­nance (ESG) fac­tors when in­vest­ing. This year the per­cent­age is down to 53%, ac­cord­ing to the ESG At­ti­tudes Sur­vey. Asked why they were over ESG, the top rea­son given was that per­for­mance was more im­por­tant.

Any­one in doubt about the mar­ket’s at­ti­tude to­ward ESG in­vest­ing to­day need only look at the share price of Im­pax As­set Man­age­ment Group Plc. It rose 33 times from late 2015 to late 2021, and is down 70% since. Bub­ble, bub­ble crash.

Clean down, dirty up

The ex­o­dus makes com­plete sense. That’s partly about per­for­mance. It’s a lot eas­ier to feel pro-ESG when it’s mak­ing you a big pile of money, as it was three years ago.

Advertise with us

It’s harder when you are un­der­perform­ing, and when the stuff you were told is ab­so­lutely not OK to touch with a barge pole is do­ing just fine. Note that the S&P Global Clean Energy In­dex is down 30% year-to-date and 12% over three years. (Low in­ter­est rates don’t suit the kind of long-du­ra­tion com­pa­nies that make up this sort of in­dex).

Mean­while, the S&P 500 Energy gauge is up 43% over the last three years. In the UK, shares of Shell Plc hit an all time high this week.

But it’s not just about per­for­mance. It’s also about the con­stantly chang­ing def­i­ni­tions of ESG. Re­mem­ber how de­fense stocks used to be Not OK.

No lon­ger. As soon as Rus­sia in­vaded Ukraine, it be­came clear to all but the most ide­o­log­i­cally blinkered that hav­ing ade­quate na­tional de­fense is the very def­i­ni­tion of a so­cial good (as­sum­ing you be­lieve in de­moc­racy and free­dom, of course).

In a war, de­fense is about as ESG as you can get. It is also one of the few ar­eas where, sadly, you can be sure the money will keep pour­ing in: Right now only 11 mem­bers of NATO spend 2% of GDP on de­fense.

Advertise with us

That will change as ev­ery­one rec­og­nizes that short-term higher de­fense spend­ing is the only op­tion and that the long-term de­ter­rence it pro­vides is the best eco­nomic in­sur­ance money can buy.

We need dirty in­dus­try

The sands have shifted in en­ergy in­vest­ing, too. Is it good gov­er­nance and a so­cial es­sen­tial to pro­vide en­ergy se­cu­rity to your pop­u­la­tion? Of course. Does that, in the short- and me­dium-terms at the very least, in­volve fos­sil fu­els?

Of course. But in the lon­ger-term it also in­volves an aw­ful lot of dig­ging, some­thing that now makes min­ing full-on ESG.

A note just out from as­set man­ager Janus Hen­der­son ti­tled “Do­ing Good Feel­ing Good” ex­plains: Many in­ves­tors have been fo­cused on in­vest­ing in firms with high ESG rat­ings and low emis­sions.

Advertise with us

But they have given too lit­tle thought to “the vast quan­ti­ties of crit­i­cal en­abling raw ma­teri­als re­quired to build the low car­bon econ­omy, such as cop­per, lith­ium, co­balt, nickel and steel and rare earths.” Yet with­out these — and the mess their ex­trac­tion causes — “there can be no low car­bon fu­ture.”

One ex­am­ple from the In­ter­na­tional Energy Agency: At the mo­ment, to­tal an­nual global nickel pro­duc­tion is around 2.8 mil­lion tons. By 2040, the elec­tric-ve­hi­cle and bat­tery-stor­age sec­tor alone will re­quire 3.3 mil­lion tons.

Green is grubby

Green is grubby. Time to ac­cept that and con­sider that per­haps these un­pleas­ant-sound­ing in­dus­tries — with their mas­sive die­sel ma­chines, low lev­els of di­ver­sity and dis­rup­tive use of re­sources such as wa­ter — are ac­tu­ally “do­ing good” by en­abling a low-car­bon fu­ture.

Th­ings need to get dirt­ier to have any hope of ever get­ting cleaner. Or as GMO’s Jer­emy Gran­tham put it, “Sorry pur­ists.”

Advertise with us

You can take this prag­matic ap­proach to ESG as far you like. Take to­bacco com­pa­nies. It would ob­vi­ously be bet­ter if they never ex­isted and if they dis­ap­peared faster.

But you have to ad­mit, they are re­mark­ably well-run: They have sur­vived lon­ger and chucked out more cash in div­i­dends for our pen­sion­ers than any­one could pos­si­bly have imag­ined when the con­se­quences of smok­ing be­came clear.

And think of the amount of tax they pour into our trea­sur­ies — cash that on some es­ti­mates out­weighs the med­i­cal costs of deal­ing with ill smok­ers and that fi­nances other parts of the state.

Is that a so­cial good? Most of us would say it’s def­i­nitely not enough of one, but you get the point: it’s hard to find ab­so­lutes.

ESG end game

Advertise with us

The idea of ESG has been chang­ing since the day it was just a twin­kle in a mar­ket­ing man’s eye. But it is now head­ing into its in­ev­i­ta­ble end game, the bit where the prag­matic can make pretty much any well-run com­pany fit one ESG met­ric or the other.

Take out the tick box “woke” el­e­ment that fund man­age­ment mar­keters have added over the last de­cade, and we are back to un­der­stand­ing that good com­pa­nies have al­ways thought about this stuff — just with­out the re­lent­less green­wash­ing and grand­stand­ing.

Mer­ryn Somer­set Webb is a se­nior col­um­nist for Bloomberg Opin­ion and host of the Mer­ryn Talks Money pod­cast.