Sympathy was once such an honorable impulse. Humble, sincere, caring. Sympathy was meant for people who suffered or had less. But now it’s disdained as a facile “poor you” of a sentiment, the equivalent of pity.
Sympathy is to be avoided. Instead, we are to upgrade to its superior, empathy. “Sympathy focuses on offering support from a distance,” a therapist explains on LinkedIn, whereas empathy “goes beyond sympathy by actively immersing oneself in another person’s emotions and attempting to comprehend their point of view.”
And from Proceedings, a publication of the U.S. Naval Institute: “Sympathy has to do with sharing emotions but is still focused on the individual who is sympathizing, rather than truly seeking to understand another’s perspective.”
Spare us your sympathy, in other words. But what what makes empathy so superior?
Sympathy vs. empathy
Etymologically speaking, sympathy was here first. It’s been in use since the 16th century, when the Greek “syn-” (”with”) combined with “pathos” (experience, misfortune, emotion, condition) to mean “having common feelings.” Empathy (the “em” means “into”) barged in from the German in the 20th century.
Read More
According to my benighted 1989 edition of Webster’s Unabridged, empathy was the more self-centered emotion. It meant “the intellectual identification with or vicarious experiencing of the feelings, thoughts or attitudes of another.”
But now sympathy implies a hierarchy, whereas empathy is the more egalitarian sentiment. Empathy, per Dictionary.com, is “the psychological identification with or vicarious experiencing of the emotions, thoughts or attitudes of another.” Sympathy stands at a haughty, “you poor dear” remove: “the act or state of feeling sorrow or compassion for another.”
No wonder, one educator said to me, he was told in a recent diversity, equity and inclusion training program that “sympathy counts for nothing.” Sympathy, the session’s leader explained, was seeing someone in a hole and saying, “Too bad you’re in a hole.” Empathy meant getting in the hole, too.
Perhaps you have heard about this hole. Brené Brown, the bestselling author, may be the one who popularized the hole metaphor, which makes a moral distinction between sympathy and empathy. “Empathy is a choice and it’s a vulnerable choice because in order to connect with you, I have to connect with something in myself that knows that feeling,” she says in a YouTube video.
According to this vision, empathy is about sharing someone else’s perspective, not offering your own.
No empathy
Still, it’s hard to square the new emphasis on empathy — you must feel what others feel — with another element of the current discourse. According to what’s known as “standpoint theory,” your view necessarily depends on your own experience: You can’t possibly know what others feel.
In his new book, “The Identity Trap,” Yascha Mounk, a professor of international affairs at Johns Hopkins, defends a modest version of this theory, writing, “It really is easy for the comparatively privileged to remain blind to the challenges faced by those who are less fortunate.” But in its more extreme interpretations, Mounk cautions, it “wrongly claims that people from different groups are incapable of empathizing with each other’s experiences of injustice — and that it would be better for them to stop trying.”
In short, no matter how much an empath you may be, unless you have actually been in someone’s place, with all its experiences and limitations, you cannot understand where that person is coming from. The object of your empathy may find it presumptuous of you to think that you “get it.”
“Empathy is asking too much,” Paul Bloom, a professor of psychology at the University of Toronto and the author of “Against Empathy,” told me. In an article in The Boston Review, he asks us to imagine what empathy demands should a friend’s child drown. “A highly empathetic response would be to feel what your friend feels, to experience, as much as you can, the terrible sorrow and pain,” he writes. “In contrast, compassion involves concern and love for your friend, and the desire and motivation to help, but it need not involve mirroring your friend’s anguish.”
Bloom argues for a more rational, modulated, compassionate response. Something that sounds a little more like our old friend sympathy.
A sympathetic hand
So why not on occasion hold out a hand to sympathy instead? Return to the idea that charitable feeling from afar isn’t inherently suspect and that in some situations, the best you can do is “merely” sympathize.
When someone cries uncontrollably next to you, you may not need to cry too, and the person may not want you to anyway. You could instead say, “I’m truly sorry” or “That’s so unfair.”
It’s perfectly fine and perhaps better than fine to admit, “I cannot possibly know what it’s like to have a miscarriage/fight in a war/get cancer.” No need to be sorry about offering your sympathies.
Pamela Paul is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. Her previous article was “Don't call prostitution 'sex work'."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.