Philosophers and psychologists refer to the “paradox of happiness,” which says that if you pursue happiness directly you will probably not be successful. You are more likely to find happiness if you pursue it indirectly. If you are too driven to be happy, for example, you will probably be too anxious and prone to disappointment as you run into obstacles to find happiness.

Similarly, there’s a “paradox of centrism” in politics. An increasing number of American citizens and political theorists and pundits have for America to overcome polarization and become more centrist.

Perhaps the most well-known organization seeking centrism is No Labels. They recently published a handbook of centrist goals, and they have an insurance policy of running (though not funding) a centrist ticket of a Democrat and Republican for president and vice-president if their research shows that the ticket might win.

Paradox of centrism

Advertise with us

The paradox of centrism requires a different approach. First, it assumes that changing the American political system will take many years, certainly five to ten. It is probably a generational goal. Nevertheless, it must be started somewhere.

Second, we should not push for a centrist political party because this will paint a target on the back of the centrist point of view. If you attack the Democrats and Republicans head on, you are riding your bicycle into two trucks. We need an indirect approach to advancing centrist goals, be they moderate centrist goals or more ambitious new centrist goals.

It will be more difficult for the two major parties to undermine an indirect approach. Indeed, it may be hard to tell which actions are part of the approach itself, and thus it may be hard to trip up these actions.

Third, the paradox of the centrism camp believes that the goal of bipartisanship must be replaced with tri-partisanship: Democrat, Republican and centrist. The goal of getting Democrats and Republicans in Washington to work together and pass major bipartisan legislation is not realistic in the current political environment. Seeking tripartisan solutions is a better mid-range and long-range goal.

In order to get to tripartisanship, we need enough independents in the House and the Senate to create a third force in American politics. These independents do not all need to be political centrists. To the contrary, they can come from all ideological perspectives, from libertarian to green and including moderate centrists and ambitious centrists that try to transcend mainstream politics and arrive at creative solutions to problems.

Advertise with us

We need independents

Charles Wheelan, professor of economics at Dartmouth College, argued in “The Centrist Manifesto” that a centrist political party needed to elect five to six independents to the U.S. Senate as part of a leverage strategy, what he called “The Fulcrum Strategy.” This approach failed in 2018. It was too direct. Better to just elect independents and let them exert leverage against the two major parties.

We of course need structural changes to the political system, notably ranked choice voting and open primaries. But the key is to work indirectly towards centrist solutions, which includes ambitious new centrist solutions and not only split the difference between centrist solutions.

We do that by electing independents to the U.S. Senate. There are three now. How to get the five or six we need is a huge question. But pursuing that goal is more likely to get us to moderate or ambitious centrist legislation in Washington, when no one can compel the Democrats and Republicans in Washington today to arrive at bipartisan, centrist solutions to our policy challenges in the areas of immigration, guns, racial relations, energy, LGBTQ rights, the environment, and family policy.

Dave Anderson edited “Leveraging: A Political, Economic and Societal Framework.”