One of the notable dynamics of American life today is that conservatives report being personally happier than liberals but also seem more politically discontented. The political left has become more institutionalist, more invested in experts and establishments, even as progressive culture seems more shadowed by unhappiness and even mental illness. What about the political right?

Meanwhile conservatives claim greater contentment in their private lives — and then go out and vote for paranoid outsiders and burn-it-down populists. The view that “my life is pretty good, but the country is going to hell,” which seems to motivate a certain kind of middle-class Donald Trump supporter, could have been heard in a bar or at a barbecue in 1975 or 1990, no less than today.

There’s also clearly an increasing eagerness of conservative voters to cast protest votes against the system. Witness not only the rise and resilience of Trump but also the populist takeovers of state and local Republican Parties, the valorization of Jan. 6 and other middle fingers to normal democratic proceduralism. Witness, too, the intellectual correlative of this populism, the sense of despair over America among certain right-wing thinkers, the impulse toward desperate measures to change the national trajectory.

You can see the outline of a theory explaining this in new polling commissioned by The Wall Street Journal that traces the decline of what used to be consensus values in American society. The share of Americans saying that patriotism is very important to them fell from 70% in 1998 to 38% today. The percentage calling religion very important fell from 62% to 39% over the same period. The percentage saying that having kids was very important dropped from 59% to 30%. Only money saw its professed importance rise.

Advertise with us

Even if the extremity of the change should be doubted, it is clear that values that conservatives consider fundamental to society have experienced a generational retreat. Republicans continue to value religion, patriotism and having kids the most.

Just this trend alone suffices to explain how on the right personal stability can coexist with intensified political alienation. If you feel secure in your own values, confident that yours is a life well lived, but the society around you seems to be swinging rapidly away from those values, it’s natural to be baffled by the shift, to feel that something is badly out of joint, to decide that the entire system needs some sort of hard reboot.

And it’s easy even to fall into paranoia and conspiracy theory, because it seems so unfathomable that so many of your fellow Americans would be abandoning the tried-and-true; there must be more to it than just a national change of mind.

Then consider, too, that the entire organizing premise of post-1960s American conservatism was that the country as whole shared its values — hence the rhetoric of the “silent majority” and the “moral majority.” The problem was just an elite class of liberals, irreligious and unpatriotic but also out of touch with the breadth and depth of American society.

Remove the weight of ineffective bureaucracy, end the rule of liberal judges, and watch the country flourish: That was the effective message of Republican politicians and quite a few conservative intellectuals for a very long time.

Advertise with us

Fewer and fewer conservatives seriously believe that it’s this simple anymore. But where does conservative politics go without a traditional cultural foundation to conserve? To subcultural retreat, maybe — but if you don’t think the walls will hold, if you want a politics of restoration, it will be inescapably radical in a way that the conservatism of 30 years ago was not.

And since nobody really knows how to do a restoration, how to roll back alienation and disaffiliation and atomization, it isn’t surprising that conservative politics would often be a car-wreck, a flinging of ripe fruit against a wall, no matter how happy individual conservatives claim to be.

Ross Douthat is a New York Times columnist. His previous article was “Ten years in, Pope Francis has pleased no one.” This article originally appeared in The New York Times.