According to the USDA, our state’s milk production has dropped 6%, prompting agriculture interests to scramble to find new ways to attract dairy investment. Pennsylvania has gone from 6th to 8th place among states in milk production.
But Pennsylvania is among the top three states with the highest number of businesses in soy and almond milk production. We have 32 such businesses, while first-place California has 52 and second-place New York has 42.
Economically speaking, state investment in our state’s growing plant-based milk makes sense. But we face one barrier: the federal government’s “milk mandate.” The USDA reimburses our public schools for cow’s milk, as part of its National School Lunch Program, but no other kind. It allows no alternatives, even for students with allergies or sensitivities to cow’s milk.
While milk production declines in our state, soy and almond milk production trends upward across the nation, growing 5.2% per year on average, largely due to a high prevalence of lactose intolerance. In fact, the market worth of plant-based milk — this includes oat, almond, coconut, soy and rice milks — is expected to be worth $123.1 billion by 2030.
Soy milk in particular stands out for its health benefits. According to educators at Pennsylvania State University, soy is “one of the most versatile foods available, as well as one of the most researched in terms of its potential health benefits.” It has notable high protein, healthy fat and fiber content. Soy protein lowers LDL cholesterol and new research indicates that soy may actually lower breast cancer risk.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture says that soy milk is “part of the dairy group” with the same calcium, vitamin D, and Vitamin A similar to cow’s milk. Even the Wall Street Journal has joined the party by running with a story that taste-tests dairy alternatives to see what gives, in their words, “your latte a lift.”
Read More
And yet, soy milk remains something of an outcast or ugly stepsister to cow’s milk. We are asked to pay extra at our favorite coffee houses to have it in our lattes as a “substitution.” People’s choices can change that. But only the government can change the milk mandate.
It's really a milk mandate, because if a school does not place milk on every tray, then there will be no reimbursements. That’s the rule of this game.
But it’s not a game we should be playing, because an alarming amount of children, teens and adults — up to 80% of Black and Indigenous people, 65% of Latinos and more than 90% of Asian people — suffer from the effects of lactose intolerant. Lactose intolerance “is also very common in people of West African, Arab, Jewish, Greek and Italian descent.” The National Institutes of Health reports the majority of people across demographics have a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy.
Avoiding such a common problem is not the only advantage of plant-based milks. There are other concerns about the dairy industry and how it treats its dairy cows that have been engineered to produce milk at levels and rates that are bad for them. Dairy farms with their manure produce greenhouse gas emissions which contribute to the climate crisis.
And what about the unfairness of the government’s milk mandate? The federal government gives one industry (dairy) all the benefits of subsidies and supports, while ignoring another industry (plant-based milk) that provides a product better for the health of many American schoolchildren. The government ignores the real costs to Americans who prefer to choose soy or other plant-based milks.
The best solution for our children would be a mandate that required milk for our children, but left the choice of what kind of milk to serve in schools to the schools themselves.
Natalie Ahwesh, executive director of Humane Action Pittsburgh and director of state affairs for Animal Wellness Action. Her previous article was “Pennsylvania should follow California in the humane care of animals.” Milton Mills, an urgent care physician in Washington, D.C., is a consultant to the Center for a Humane Economy.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.