Long before there was a Veterans Administration, American veterans demanded access to services promised to them by the federal government, but not delivered. In 1833, the federal government, alongside the Navy, opened the United States Naval Asylum. Located on the Schuylkill River in Philadelphia, this institution was the nation's first federal site dedicated to long-term care for aging, disabled and impoverished veterans of the U.S. military.

Politicians and naval officials hoped the institution would be an adequate federal response to the needs of destitute old sailors, a population tha Americans then largely viewed as deserving of both private and government support. As War of 1812 hero Commodore William Bainbridge romantically described the future institution at the laying of the building's cornerstone in 1827, "A home will thus be established for the faithful tar, who has been either worn out or maimed in fighting the battles of his country — a comfortable harbour will be secured, where he may safely moor, and ride out the ebb of life, free from the cares and storms by which he has been previously surrounded."

Once open, the institution welcomed naval veterans who struggled to live independently due to injuries they received and illnesses they contracted while at sea. These veterans had multistory verandas where they could enjoy fresh air, their own private rooms and advanced plumbing for the era. Officials promised these aging tars — a popular name for common sailors used throughout the British and American Atlantic world in the 18th and 19th centuries — a refuge to live out their lives in relative comfort.

Or so they thought.

Advertise with us

By the 1840s, in addition to aging sailors, the Naval Asylum building included the Philadelphia Naval Hospital and a small school for midshipmen that was a precursor to the United States Naval Academy in Annapolis. B February 1843, services and resources had significantly declined and the asylum residents, wrote to the secretary of the Navy protesting the dire conditions.

The shared space, they lamented, forced a large group of pensioners into rooms on the building's third floor. These residents, who they described as "lame" and ill were "obliged to get the others to help us up the Stairs." The petitioners also objected to their lack of privacy from having to share rooms: "Our little rooms ... are taken away ... and [we] have lost our pride, in not being private by ourselves."

The service they most wanted, however, was an adequate lavatory. "48 Pensioners have the use of but one necessary, and that with but one seat." They understood that such inadequate resources signified a lack of appreciation for their military service. After emphasizing they were owed space in the Naval Asylum because of their service to the country, they declared, "We want to live the short time we are in the world in peace and quiet, but if our prayer is not granted, we have made up our minds not to stay here."

The acting head of the Naval Asylum called the report a set of "misrepresentations." But he did not flatly disagree with the men. In the case of lavatory, for example, he wrote, "The representations of the state of the Privy is substantially correct."

This moment in the Naval Asylum's history reveals the gap between the residents' expectations and the reality of this federal institution's shortcomings. Moreover, it marked a turning point in which officials responded in creative ways to meet those expectations.

Advertise with us

The secretary of the Navy recommended immediate changes to the allotment of space, with which the governor complied. A few years later, the midshipmen left the institution and made their educational home in Annapolis. Congress also funded the construction of a separate building for the Philadelphia Naval Hospital. With the asylum building restored to its original purpose, naval veterans continued to call the building in Philadelphia home until 1976, when the institution moved to Gulfport, Miss.

The petition demonstrates how such rightful demands for access are not only a phenomenon of modern problems such as website inaccessibility and exposure to harmful chemicals. They are rooted in a long-standing expectation that the federal government and military must provide adequate services to disabled veterans.

In 1843, the veterans' demands caught the attention of people in power and elicited a response because the nation had promised to fulfill a debt to them in exchange for their service to the country. And did, when they demanded it.

Moyra Williams Schauffler is a Ph.D. candidate at Pennsylvania State University, where she is affiliated with the George and Ann Richards Civil War Era Center. Her research focuses on U.S. veterans, institutions and histories of material culture and the built environment.