War is fundamentally about economic and political power. But no war is conducted without an appeal to transcendent ideals. The United States calls for supporting freedom, democracy, and human rights in Ukraine. Russian leaders speak of defending the Orthodox faith and traditional moral values. If peace is ever to come, not only the guns but the dueling absolutisms must fall silent.
That moment has not yet arrived. As war escalates, so does the rhetoric. When Russia launched its invasion on February 24, Putin called for the “denazification” of Ukraine. By late summer, he had shifted to accusing Ukrainian of “terrorism.” Since then, his language has only become darker.
In September, at a grand ceremony in the Kremlin to celebrate Russian annexation of occupied territories in Ukraine, Putin asserted that Russia had the right — indeed, the sacred duty — to defend itself and the Ukrainian people from Western “elites.” These liberals, he asserted, wish to impose their decadent moral values not only on Russia but also on the rest of the world. They seek to overthrow “faith and traditional values.” They are creating a “’religion in reverse’ — pure Satanism.”
A month later, Patriarch Kirill, head of the Russian Orthodox Church, made a similar argument, citing words of the Apostle Paul, “We are not contending against flesh and blood, but ... against the world rulers of this present darkness, against the spiritual hosts of wickedness in the heavenly places.” Without mentioning Ukraine by name, he told his audience, “You know what I’m talking about.” Some news outlets hurried to fill in the blanks: Putin is the “exorcist” who will save Russia and, indeed, all humanity from the “Antichrist.”
These ideas resonate with many Russians. The collapse of the Soviet Union left them demoralized. The economy hit bottom, and political life was chaotic. Moreover, Russians perceived the West as trying to reduce them to just another submissive European country, with a GNP and military even weaker than their neighbors’. Something deep in the Russian soul protested, “We may no longer be a superpower, but we are still a great nation with a distinctive history and culture. We can be proud, rather than humiliated.”
Orthodox Christianity has become an essential dimension of that distinctive, proud identity. In Manhattan and London, skyscraper monuments to banking and commerce dominate, but in Moscow, gold and silver onion domes of new and historic churches rise up against the horizon. Not the Enlightenment ideals of America’s founding fathers, but rather Orthodoxy’s ancient language has become mainstream political coinage.
Read More
Russians may not attend church — in Moscow, less than one percent are in Sunday services — but religious categories of thinking help them make sense of their nation again. What makes Russia “Russia” is its divine mission to protect Christianity from the barbarians.
Putin and Kirill argue that the West’s celebration of same-sex marriage, transgenderism, and genetic engineering threaten humanity with a transhumanism that would violate our very God-given nature. But, Kirill declares, there is still time. If Russians stand up to defend their traditions and homeland (read between the lines, “prevail in Ukraine”), they will set a sign of hope that the world needs: “the possibility of altering the course of history and preventing a global apocalyptic ending.”
Kirill’s allusions to Satan and the apocalypse — and, in Putin’s case, also to nuclear weapons — mean that the stakes cannot be higher. “He who is not with me,” Jesus once said, “is against me.” There can be no compromise with Satan. Religious language turns the conflict over Ukraine into an Armageddon: Russia against the West, Good against Evil, and the salvation of humankind against its demise.
Ukrainians, also historically an Orthodox people, have not hesitated to throw Putin’s and Kirill’s harsh rhetoric right back at them: “Russia is headed by Nazis, Russia is a terrorist state, and Russia needs desatanization.”
At its best (which it not always is), Christianity, like other religious traditions, rejects language that deepens hatred. Rather, all of us — Russians, Ukrainians, and Americans alike — have reason to examine ourselves and to become more humble, more repentant. There is only one Absolute, a transcendent God, who demands responsible human action, yet who calls every human absolutism into question.
If it proceeds from this distinctly religious perspective, the West will carefully examine its motives for assisting Ukraine, while rejecting Russia’s absolutist slogans and questioning its own. Yes, the fate of Ukraine and perhaps more is at stake, but Christ warned his followers not to speculate about the end of the world. That is not in our hands.
To be sure, how to bring this brutal war to an end remains frustratingly elusive. Much of our American debate focuses on weapons — which, how many, and for how long. Answers are rarely clear. To quote the Apostle again, “for now we see through a glass, darkly.”
But a small beginning toward a just peace might be language that is more thoughtful, categories of thought that are more nuanced. Talk of Satan and the apocalypse does not help.
John P. Burgess is professor of theology at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary and the author of “‘Holy Rus’: The Rebirth of Orthodoxy in the New Russia.” His previous article was “Why Patriarch Kirill will not condemn Russia's invasion of Ukraine.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.