Millions of people looked forward to the day they could sign on to the website. The event was well publicized, and anxious users, eager to get what they wanted, stayed up late to place their orders as soon as possible. But while they repeatedly attempted to get into the site, they received constant error messages to “try again later.” In the end, the site suffered a catastrophic crash, leaving millions frustrated.
This sounds like the website crash that recently disappointed Taylor Swift fans, but the crash actually took place almost a decade ago on a government website. Healthcare.gov was built to sign up Americans for medical coverage that became known as “Obamacare.” With years of construction time and legions of expensive contractors, the government could not get the site to function for the millions who tried to shop for health care.
It is unfortunate that pop music fans were unable to purchase tickets to see one of their favorite musicians. The Ticketmaster site had not anticipated the traffic volume, and as sometimes happens, the system crashed. Both Ticketmaster and Taylor Swift issued apologies and commitments to rectify the issue.
These mea culpas did not satisfy members of Congress. Democratic senator Amy Klobuchar has called for a Senate hearing to “probe Ticketmaster.” She’s taken the lead, but Mike Lee, her Republican colleague on the Subcommittee on Competition Policy, Antitrust, and Consumer Rights, has joined her.
Let me repeat that. Two U.S. senators are urging the Senate to investigate a system of purchasing seats for a music concert. This call for use of government time and resources was made in all seriousness, despite the fact that systems crash all the time, including on sites operated by the government.
When asked about the failure of the Healthcare.gov, then President Obama gave a laundry list of excuses. He blamed “all the crises we are dealing with,” citing the economy, auto industry problems, war. Essentially, he was asking Americans to give his administration a pass for nonperformance. After all, computer stuff is hard, and the economy is in bad shape.
Read More
Of course, we need to have a little perspective here. The consumers in 2013 were only trying to purchase health care. This need pales in comparison to acquiring a balcony seat to hear “Highway Don’t Care.”
But joking aside, what is driving Sen. Klobuchar’s call for hearings? It is about Evil Corporations. The merger between Ticketmaster and LiveNation has long been a target of disdain by Congress members who feel big business should be smaller and have more government oversight. Several lawmakers have waged verbal wars against on-line businesses, in particular vilifying the big tech companies that power the web.
In fact, President Obama, in trying to defend the government’s incompetence on the health care site, pointed to Google, Facebook and Twitter as resources to help fix the site. Wait a second. Google, Facebook, Twitter? Aren’t these businesses top targets of senators on both sides of the aisle? Yes. And now we can add Ticketmaster to the list of companies that must be crushed and controlled.
What is really going on here? Is this just an attempt for a senator to grab headlines? Does she really believe that congressional resources should be expended to investigate how concert tickets are sold? How does any of this make a meaningful difference in the lives of her constituents?
I suggest that a couple other problems may need Congress’ attention more — the economy, inflation, funding foreign wars, deteriorating personal rights, to name a few. But instead, she wants our elected officials to spend their limited time and our resources on a problem that probably does not exist.
The market tends to punish non-performers — sites that crash, for example — and reward those who make customers happy. Unhappy consumers and artists will expect a fix that addresses their needs. The market will pressure Ticketmaster to do better, with a senate hearing.
One way is supplying alternatives. Just a few years ago, people worried that Tesla was a near-monopoly and might continue to dominate the market. Other companies saw an opening and took it. It had 79% of the market just two years ago. Now it’s 65%, and experts predict it may be under 20% in 2025.
I hope that Sen. Klobuchar’s customers let her know that they expect her to address the real needs of the nation, which does not include a set of aisle seats in Row J.
Liz Terwilliger, an early intervention speech pathologist living in Warren Center, Pa., is a founding member of Reform Congress. Her previous article was “Even your DNA isn't your own. The government can take it without a warrant.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.