President Joe Biden continues to hammer the nation’s banks for charging overdraft fees. Who wouldn’t welcome the chance to avoid paying a fee for a bounced check? But Biden’s initiative is not without consequences.

First, it makes it harder for banks to guard against overdrafts. A bounced check basically is an unsecured loan that still involves bank employees or a paid third-party vendor to reconcile. The Biden plan makes it harder for banks to recover their costs.

Some banks may choose to recover these costs elsewhere — like eliminating free checking, which discourages the unbanked from opening accounts. Some banks may choose to drop overdraft protections altogether, which will send shockwaves through the economy.

Second, Biden’s plan treats small community and rural banks the same as large national banks, to the detriment of the communities they serve. Biden’s plan is more costly to community banks, whose operations are smaller and leaner than big banks. The tradeoff is that community bank customers get more tailored and customized services, focused on the local area.

Advertise with us

My group, the Pennsylvania Association of Community Bankers, represents small and independent financial institutions that are essential to their communities, funding 70% of small business loans and supporting local charitable causes. Our members originated $3.5 billion in PPP loans, saving 150,000 Pennsylvania jobs. Our members often are called “relationship” banks.

Many financial institutions offer overdraft privileges to protect their customers. Account holders with insufficient funds may use the bank’s assets to cover an overdraft (for a small fee). That helps them avoid much higher fees, late payments and interest charges. With a separate product called overdraft protection, an account holder uses their own funds, in the form of a savings account, line of credit, or credit card, to cover an account overdraft.

Existing laws already protect account holders. They have the choice to opt in or out of protection; they may choose to have the transaction declined instead. They do not have to pay fees they did not agree to. It is illegal for banks to deceive them and impose arbitrary or unfair fines and fees.

PACB members openly disclose fees and terms to depositors. There are no surprises. We base our charges on market forces and the need to safeguard outside vendors. Our customers do not pay for a bank’s mistake.

This personal touch allows us to quickly notify customers about changes to their accounts. It helps them take the necessary steps to make payments on time. We can forestall late payments that might otherwise result in foreclosure or repossession.

Advertise with us

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB) own data shows that large banks collect most consumer fees. In fact, of the $15.4 billion collected in 2019, 44% was assessed by just three massive banks. By contrast, community banks with less than $1 billion in assets collected only 7.3 percent.

While the president boasted that he has “pushed banks to reduce their fees,” the CFPB found that community banks have not increased their reliance on overdraft fees. The CFPB has accused the nation’s financial institutions of engaging in “complex back-office practices.” For our part, community banks are just trying to serve their customers.

Good actors should not be punished for the actions of others. Treating community banks the same as large national banks only will hasten the move toward bank consolidation, which is already occurring rapidly. That would defeat the very purpose of a community bank, which is to serve the towns and rural communities overlooked by others.

I don’t believe this is the outcome the president seeks. The president should put down his hammer and work with us to make a positive impact on the communities we serve.

Kevin L. Shivers is president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Association of Community Bankers.