The majority Supreme Court opinion in Dobbs overturning Roe v. Wade returns us to the 1850s, when a similar national debate concerned enslaved Black people. Some argued that since the Constitution did not explicitly prohibit slavery (just as it does not explicitly guarantee the right to privacy), then each territory and state should vote to be slave or free.

Given the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 (which allowed for “popular sovereignty”), and the Dred Scott decision of 1857, federal decisions and statutes affirmed that enslaved people had no rights anywhere in the Union. Slavery, voted up by one state legislature, must in some sense be respected by all states.

As Lincoln feared, that meant that no state or territory could exclude slavery permanently. A fugitive slave in a free state remained enslaved. Under the Fugitive Slave Act, all citizens, under penalty of imprisonment and fines, were enjoined to capture and return that fugitive.

Lincoln’s “House Divided” speech of June 16, 1858 foresaw that the nation would become either all slave or all free: “And this may especially be expected if the doctrine of ‘care not whether slavery be voted down or voted up,’ shall gain upon the public mind sufficiently to give promise that such a decision can be maintained when made.”

Advertise with us

Read: “care not whether a woman’s right to choose be voted down or voted up.” According to the Court’s majority, that right depends on where she lives, although she often has no choice where to live. Women now suffer a geographical morality.

Today, some states are entertaining or have already passed laws concerning abortion that legally target any individual who helps to provide abortions. Other states, such as Connecticut, have passed legislation that protects from extradition its own citizens who aid women from other states who seek abortion care.

While Justice Brett Kavanaugh opines that there is no reason to believe that the right of interstate travel can be restricted (say, to obtain an abortion), some states, such as Missouri, seem poised to test this view.

What might be the next step? It’s no secret. Anti-abortion advocates want a woman’s right to choose to exist in no state. Presumably, they would welcome a Fugitive Women’s Act. Using cell phone and computer data collected and brokered commercially, it is possible to trace the movements of a woman who travels across state lines, even to the location of specific clinics.

Moreover, federal decisions affirming contraception — and interracial and gay marriage, as well as LGBTQ rights — are based on reasoning akin to that in Roe v. Wade. Might the rights of those individuals be decided state by state, too?

Advertise with us

Justice Clarence Thomas, in a concurring opinion, called for overturning all personal privacy protections. A couple could be legally married in some states, not in others. A person who was not a straight heterosexual could hold a job, marry, and adopt children in some states, but in others be violating the law. The country would be half one thing, half another.

With respect to women’s rights, it already is. Twenty-six states either now outlaw abortion or soon may.

Many of those states mandate carrying any pregnancy to term, including one in which a thirteen-year-old is carrying the child of her rapist, who might be her father, stepfather, or uncle. Such laws seem abhorrent to many.

But, in theory, given the Court’s grotesque reasoning, state legislatures could even pass laws mandating abortion.

As long as some states permit abortion, opponents of a woman’s right to choose will not stop trying to outlaw it. Many of the women who will be hurt are minorities. Many are poor.

Advertise with us

Yet, overturning Roe v. Wade invites more sweeping actions by a Republican Congress and this Supreme Court. When the 1850s ended, the Confederacy soon enshrined slavery in its constitution: no confederate state could abolish it. Any new Confederate territory must allow it.

Citizens who believe in a woman’s right to choose should, in the words of Frederick Douglass, “use all honorable means” to oppose what Lincoln in the late 1850s called the political “machinery” working to perpetuate and extend slavery. A similar machinery with different goals has been working, step by step for decades, to deny a woman’s right to choose.

Former President Trump stated that he would appoint only justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade. That machinery has placed three comparatively young justices on the Court. (Senators Susan Collins and Joe Manchin now say they were “misled” by one of them.)

This is precisely the kind of political machinery once used to enshrine slavery. And it does not intend to stop its machinations.

James Engell is the Gurney Professor of English Literature and Professor of Comparative Literature at Harvard University.