In recent years, signs and T-shirts bearing the slogan "We Are the Granddaughters of the Witches You Couldn't Burn" have popped up at political protests and rallies for a variety of causes, from #MeToo to reproductive rights. The phrase powerfully evokes the history of witch hunts as attacks on politically active women.

In 1692, in Salem and elsewhere across early America and the Atlantic world, witches were thought to have made a pact with Satan to unleash "maleficia" — or harmful magic — upon their communities, causing sickness, misery and death. Accusations were overwhelmingly hurled at women, particularly those who were poor or older. Trials engaged the entire community as a form of popular entertainment and visible social control over women's behavior and authority.

The trials in Salem stand out among other witch trials in colonial America because they were so lethal and extreme. Within less than a year, 19 individuals were hanged, six others died in legal custody and hundreds suffered from the damaging legal accusations.

But the accused and their families did not passively accept their fate. During Elizabeth How's (also spelled Howe) legal examination, for example, the mother of six insisted, "If it was the last moment I was to live, God knows I am innocent of anything in this nature." Even after she was executed, her family fought to restore her honor.

Advertise with us

Family members of the falsely accused began submitting petitions asking for their loved ones' convictions to be overturned within a few years of the trials, pushing the legislature to exonerate the falsely accused in 1711. How's daughters Abigail and Mary were paid restitution shortly after.

In subsequent centuries, activists continued to point to Salem and other witch hunts as defining moments of injustice and misogyny. Matilda Joslyn Gage was an ardent suffragist, abolitionist and advocate for Indigenous rights who held more radical views than many of her contemporaries, including her once-collaborators Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton.

In 1893, she published "Woman, Church & State," which identified the "witch" stigma as a historical source of women's oppression. She contended that "the extreme wickedness of woman" was "taught as a cardinal doctrine," with "witchcraft being regarded as [woman's] strongest weapon" against Christian society.

Gage decried these beliefs and pointed to how the persecution of witchcraft produced acts of physical violence against women, as well as causing great psychological, spiritual and economic harm. "It is impossible for us at the present day to conceive the awful horror falling upon a family into which an accusation of witchcraft had come," she wrote.

Gage's words echoed in the burgeoning field of women's studies 80 years later. Amid the 1960s groundswell of various and diverse liberation movements, Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English pointed to a centuries-old tradition of "wise women" healers.

Advertise with us

These women, they argued, held essential knowledge and skills that granted them stature at a time when women held very little formal power. As a result, beginning in the 15th century, such women were derided as "witches" by male religious and medical authorities, whose ire led to the spread of deadly witch hunts.

While some of the historical details in the book are today debated, their polemical tome was crucial to the growth of the reproductive health movement and to modern feminist reclamations of the "witch" as an archetype of resistance. Activists, who recognized that the stigma had been weaponized against women and other marginalized people who refused to conform to society's expectations for centuries, used the mantle of the "witch" to draw attention to ongoing struggles for women's liberation.

In 1968, activists from New York Radical Women founded Women's International Terrorist Conspiracy from Hell (WITCH), for example. The group's first action was a demonstration "hexing" Wall Street on Halloween: The group donned witch costumes and used street theater to protest patriarchy and capitalism.

Their manifesto declared, "​​There is no 'joining' WITCH. If you are a woman and dare to look within yourself, you are a Witch. ​​You make your own rules."

Similarly, in 1976, the radical, anti-capitalist feminist collective Wages for Housework organized a May Day march in Naples, in which 3,000 women chanted, "Tremble, tremble, the witches are returning, not to be burnt but to be paid!"

Advertise with us

Beyond metaphorically taking on the witch mantle, some feminists in this period looked to witchcraft as an alternative to organized religion, which they increasingly identified as patriarchal. Women like Zsuzsanna Budapest and Starhawk reinterpreted nature-based, Wiccan and Pagan beliefs thought to have roots predating Christianity into new fluid, nondogmatic practices and belief systems.

The spiritual healers, shamans, Wiccan high priestesses, Neo-Pagans, occultists, mystics, herbalists and activists reclaim power on their own terms, subverting the witch taboo in favor of a complex and holistic state of being rooted in diverse spiritual traditions.

Some define their practice in ways that are inextricable from their political identities. As Mya Spalter explains, "Witchcraft informs my worldview. It's intensely political to believe in the oneness of life on Earth." Leonore Tjia argues: "In a culture as racist and patriarchal and transphobic and homophobic and materialistic as ours is, if you don't see the way witchcraft is radical and revolutionary, you have some waking up to do."

With threats to women's hard-won and contested liberties looming after the reversal of Roe v. Wade and increasing discrimination against LGBTQ+ individuals, we can look to how generations of activists have reclaimed the witch archetype to resist patriarchal control and stand up to injustice in their own lives.

Anna K. Danziger Halperin is the associate director of the Center for Women's History at the New York Historical Society, and is writing a book on the history of child care debates. She commends "The Salem Witch Trials: Reckoning and Reclaiming," an exhibit at the Peabody Essex Museum in Salem, Ma., which is on view through Jan. 22.