In 2006, Pennsylvania played a crucial role in the Democrats’ takeover of Congress. It may play the opposite role this year. Then, working-class voters booted out GOP incumbents, especially in the state’s west and northeast, and so did suburbanites, particularly in Philadelphia’s historically Republican “collar” counties.

Angry at the Bush administration for the Iraq war, voters saw the Republicans as out-of-touch on the economy and veering too far rightward on social issues. As one Democratic strategist described the situation to the Philadelphia Inquirer, the anger toward Republicans was “explosive.” “They were saying to these guys in power: ‘Rethink things. Stop being so doctrinaire and single-minded.’”

Now, in counties like Westmoreland, Republicans now dominate formerly Democratic strongholds. Traditionally Democratic counties like Luzerne, Northampton, and Erie have become prime Trump territory where Democrats continue to lose voters. This year in the state, 53,091 Democrats became Republicans, while only 19,477 Republicans became Democrats.

In recent years, the Keystone State has undergone an economic and demographic transformation. It’s become a global hub for warehousing, for instance, and its eds-and-meds-driven suburbs are increasingly diverse and prosperous. Meanwhile, numerous eastern Pennsylvania cities now have Hispanic-majority populations. And its working-class regions, which once elected local Democratic machines and fueled the U.S. labor movement, have never been more Republican.

Advertise with us

As a recent Muhlenberg College survey found, the economy and inflation overwhelmingly prevail as top issues for Pennsylvania voters. This is evident among business owners, who struggle to find workers, but also the state’s large senior population, especially in its 48 rural counties. Many are on fixed incomes and suffer from rising inflation and rising taxes.

The Biden administration’s economic response has only intensified the movement of many Pennsylvanians, in regions like the anthracite coal region and the Lehigh Valley, to vote Republican.

“I’ve been in business since 1974,” one construction company owner told PennLive’s John Luciew. “I have seen a whole lot of ups and downs in the country. But never quite like this. This is really bad. Prices are out of hand. And everything, the way it’s being handled by the current administration, it’s upside down.”

Democrats’ energy messaging doesn’t play well in Pennsylvania. More than half of state households use natural gas for heating fuel and where polling shows voters in both parties believe domestic gas and oil production helps lower costs.

Crime has also figured as a top concern for Pennsylvania voters, who don’t subscribe to progressive solutions on criminal-justice matters. This issue placed Democratic Senate candidate John Fetterman in a vulnerable electoral position, even before his troubling debate performance last week.

Advertise with us

As lieutenant governor, he chairs the state’s Board of Pardons, where his leadership, including a push for clemency, reflects what the Philadelphia Inquirer describes as “the heart of an activist and, at times, the force of a bully.” But such activism isn’t a sentiment shared by Pennsylvania voters, particularly those facing crime and quality-of-life problems in their neighborhoods.

Pittsburgh, where progressives have made significant judicial inroads in recent local elections, faces its own crime crisis. The homicide rate, for instance, stands at its highest rate in the past seven years.

Downtown residents have expressed disgust with the city’s direction. One downtown apartment building manager described a “huge increase in crime, pervasive homelessness,” and “open-air drug abuse and sales.”

The crime concern also applies to Pennsylvania’s smaller cities, including Johnstown, Hazleton, and Williamsport, where in August the district attorney’s office issued a release declaring that young gang members “do not fear acts of violence.”

In Luzerne County, the district attorney recently lamented how his office is stretched thin as it assists short-staffed police departments with rising crime. “You know, the number of homicides hasn’t really gone up. The number of people that get shot and survive has increased dramatically,” the county’s district attorney told WNEP.

Advertise with us

Just days before Election Day, whether in northeastern Pennsylvania or even pockets of suburban Philadelphia, voter discontent — especially on economic and public-safety concerns — is directed toward Democrats. Their view of the Democrats this year echoes Pennsylvanians’ impression of Republicans in 2006: “doctrinaire and single-minded.”

They have reason. At a virtual event this summer, Democratic U.S. Rep. Susan Wild — perhaps the state’s most vulnerable congressional incumbent — said that she “might have to school” voters in the district’s Carbon County, once a Democratic stronghold.

“I’m not quite sure what was in their heads because the people of Carbon County are exactly the kind of people who should not be voting for a Donald Trump,” she said. How can Democrats hold the votes of people they think so ignorant of their own best interests?

In his September speech in Philadelphia, President Joe Biden warned of the “extremism” of “MAGA Republicans.” But the problem for Democrats, at least in Pennsylvania, is that vast numbers of such Republicans voted for Barack Obama in 2008 and even 2012. In recent years, following Trump’s election, they switched party affiliation because they no longer believed that Democrats represented their economic and cultural interests.

As the polls stand as I write, Fetterman and Oz are essentially tied. And the mood, especially after the debate, isn’t on Fetterman’s side. If anything, like 2006, even congressional and down-ballot races could go to the party out of office.

Advertise with us

An exception is the governor’s race. Democratic candidate and current state attorney general Josh Shapiro has run a centrist and highly disciplined campaign — one reminiscent of successful statewide moderate GOP campaigns in the past.

His opponent, Doug Mastriano, veered to the right of the average Pennsylvania voter, who, for example, takes a nuanced position on abortion and supports gay marriage. In Pennsylvania’s suburbs, voters are receptive to Republicans’ message on crime and the economy but in most instances are averse to staunch conservatism on social concerns.

For example, one typical suburban Philadelphia Republican voter questioned if Mastriano could be trusted as governor. “I think he’s too far conservative,” she told WHYY. “I think he will cause more of a divide in our state if he gets in as governor.”

What does this mean for Tuesday? Shapiro clearly has the upper hand in the governor’s race. But in In my conversations throughout Pennsylvania, where I’ve traveled extensively this year, expressions of local discontent have consistently translated into anger toward Democrats. This mood doesn’t bode well for the party next Tuesday.

Charles F. McElwee is editor of RealClearPennsylvania. Follow him on Twitter at @CFMcElwee.