Many years ago, I was invited to a dinner intended to raise money for a medical charity. My host told me that I would be sitting next to Dr. Julius Axelrod. How bad can that be, I thought? With most doctors, I knew, the secret to a good conversation is to resist the temptation to seek a diagnosis for whatever ails you.
It then occurred to me that it was odd to be told weeks ahead of time who my dinner companion would be. I asked my host whether I should know anything about Dr. Axelrod. He responded: “Dr. Axelrod won the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1970.” Oh.
When I met Dr. Axelrod that evening, he was pushing 90 years old. He wore a patch over an eye that had been blinded years before in a laboratory accident. He was the son of Polish immigrants, and his demeanor was modest and reserved. How to break the ice?
After exchanging pleasantries, I asked him where he attended medical school. He responded that he had not attended medical school and rather had earned advanced research degrees.
How stupid of me. You don’t typically win a Nobel Prize by brandishing a stethoscope. Of course, he would be a Ph.D. in a scientific field, and indeed he had authored the foundational breakthroughs for classes of drugs including Prozac and Zoloft. I apologized to this extraordinary scientist for my ignorance. He smiled and said that he had wanted to attend medical school in the 1930s but his applications to leading schools had been rejected.
My mind raced to the hapless admissions officers who had rejected the applications of this future Nobel laureate. But then Dr. Axelrod told me why he had been rejected. The “Jewish Quotas” of that period had been filled by the time his applications had been received. The merits of his applications had not been reached. He was a Jew.
Read More
Let’s get this straight: Seven decades after Benjamin Disraeli had become the United Kingdom’s first Jewish Prime Minister and two decades after Woodrow Wilson had nominated and the U.S. Senate had confirmed Louis Brandeis as our first Jewish Supreme Court Justice, Julius Axelrod was turned down at major medical schools because he was a Jew. My stomach turned at that charity dinner, but I was grateful that our society had evolved past that noxious stage.
Decades later, I see that my gratitude has been misplaced. Today, the United States Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in “Students for Fair Admissions Inc. v. President & Fellows of Harvard College.”
This case (along with another case involving the University of North Carolina) will address whether higher education institutions can use race as a factor in admission decisions and whether Harvard has unlawfully penalized Asian American applicants through an overemphasis on race in the admissions process. Most of the higher education establishment has united behind Harvard and against the Asian American students.
The crux of the dispute is that Asian American students consistently score higher than other ethnic and racial groups on objective metrics such as grades and test scores but lower on subjective personal rating scores assigned by Harvard admissions officers such as “likeability,” “helpfulness” and “good human qualities.” Really?
I know many white Harvard graduates. Their professional and scholarly achievements have arguably made the world a better place. If their college applications had been evaluated based on “likeability,” however, not all would have Harvard sweatshirts in their closets. And my Asian American friends have been among the most enjoyable, collegial, and trustworthy folks I’ve ever met.
Sixty percent of the world’s population lives in Asia. Some small fraction of the Asian population has made it to our shores. Those families are generally American success stories.
Although the test scores and grades of their children are consistently higher than those of their African American, Hispanic American, and white American contemporaries, Harvard turns many of them down on racial grounds. Indeed, as the Boston Herald reported, “Harvard’s own internal investigation found that ‘demographic factors’ alone reduced the share of admitted Asian Americans by 30% while increasing the proportion of Hispanic admissions by 140% and blacks by a jaw-dropping 370%.”
For over two centuries, the Supreme Court has decided cases with extraordinary implications for our culture. The most famous example is Brown v. Board of Education overruling Plessy v. Ferguson’s approval of racial segregation laws. Does the Harvard case also present an opportunity profoundly to change our culture?
I would offer an emphatic “yes,” because it’s high time to resurrect and revitalize the merit principle in all facets of American life and to banish race as a validating principle for important decisions. As a polestar for human development, identity is as inadequate a substitute for excellence in the 21st Century as it was in the 19th and 20th.
Instead of discriminating against Asian Americans, perhaps we should figure out why they outperform other classes of applicants and learn from them. And if Harvard truly wishes to diversify its class, perhaps it should focus on poor kids regardless of race.
Chief Justice Roberts once wrote: “The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” If the Supreme Court sides with the Asian American students, will higher education comply with Chief Justice Roberts’ prescription or will we see a resistance movement emerge? Our nation’s future may hang in the balance.
Peter Kalis served for 20 years as chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates LLP. He clerked for Supreme Court Justice Byron White. His previous article was “The time I met the queen.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.