So great was Pittsburgh’s Civil War production of shot and shell that some historians refer to the city as the “Arsenal of the Union.” It was also, as a result, the site of the largest civilian disaster during the Civil War.
Nestled between 39th and 40th just off Butler Street in Lawrenceville sits Arsenal Park, where the Allegheny Arsenal once stood. Established in 1814 to produce cannonballs for Commodore Perry’s fleet battling the British on Lake Erie during the War of 1812, the Arsenal became one of the America’s principal ordnance innovators and producers of ammunition for small arms and artillery in the years before the Civil War.
From 1861 to 1865, the sprawling complex of shops and laboratories on the banks of the Allegheny River turned out millions of rounds of musket cartridges and a wide range of shot for the horse-drawn field artillery needed by the Union armies to battle the rebelling Southern states of the Confederacy.
Filling musket cartridges proved to be a delicate and dangerous process. Children — some as young as 10 years old and many of them female — filled the cartridges with their small and nimble hands.
On September 17, 1862, something went terribly wrong. A series of massive explosions erupted near the Arsenal’s primary laboratory, destroying the building and its surrounding structures.
The blasts instantly killed 78 civilians — mostly young girls — and burned or maimed many more. Local volunteer firemen courageously fought to extinguish the flames, only to find that little was left but the spring steel hoop skirt frames worn by female workers.
Read More
Military investigations concluded that the cause of the disaster “could not be determined.” The cause of the explosion remains a mystery to this day.
Though fire destroyed the cartridge laboratories and other arsenal buildings, it did not affect the shops closer to the river, where men and boys loaded artillery shells intended for the muzzle-loading bronze and iron cannons used during this period.
The shops continued producing field artillery rounds, called 6-pounders, 12-pounders, and 24-pounders, depending on the weight of the solid shot.
Arsenal workers prepared four types of projectiles: Solid iron balls (solid shot), clusters or cans of small iron or lead balls (case shot known as grapeshot and canister), exploding iron balls filled with lead shrapnel balls (spherical case shot), and hollow iron exploding balls (shell).
Artillerists of the day used solid shot to batter enemy fortifications, disable opposing cannons, or bounce on the ground through massed infantry formations. Though not very powerful because of their small charges of black powder, exploding case shot scattered lead shrapnel balls, invented by British Captain Henry Shrapnel. Shell might be used to ignite enemy caissons (ammunition wagons) and powder magazines.
Historians believe that when Allegheny Arsenal was decommissioned in 1905, stacked pyramids of obsolete cannonballs were used as fill as new construction replaced the old buildings, despite their explosive potential.
In 1972, while digging footings for a warehouse less than 75 yards from the recently discovered cannonballs, workers found 1250 balls, mostly 6-pounder and 12-pounder. Most of these were packed in barrels filled with water and removed to Picatinny Arsenal in New Jersey. About 20 were unloaded to be examined and analyzed. The rest were destroyed, though some wound up in the hands of private collectors.
Only a dozen specimens found their way to the collection of the Heinz History Center, where they are exhibited today. Much information was lost to history.
More recently, in 2017 and 2020, construction companies excavating the Allegheny Arsenal site for the construction of new apartments discovered hundreds of Civil War-era cannonballs. In both cases, the contractors alerted the bomb squad and precautions were taken to keep nearby residents safe from the more than 150-year-old artillery projectiles.
The discovery of the cannonball caches at the Allegheny Arsenal site is exciting for all of us who study Civil War history, representing a rare window to the past. Many questions can be answered by a careful inspection of the site and an analysis of the cannonballs.
Army ordnance disposal teams destroyed thousands of the cannonballs. Fortunately, Congressman Conor Lamb contacted Marine Corps ordnance experts who worked with Heinz History Center curators to safely "inert" and study a handful of specimens.
Examining these artifacts can reveal much about our industrial past at an important time in American history — a time when Pittsburgh was the smoky Iron City and the Arsenal of the Union.
Andrew E. Masich is the president and CEO of the Senator John Heinz History Center. This evening, Oct. 28, the center is hosting a discussion with authors Tom Powers and James Wudarczyk of the Lawrenceville Historical Society to examine the legends, lore, and myths surrounding the Allegheny Arsenal.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.