This article is one of a series of opinion pieces the Post-Gazette will be running until the election, addressing the issues at stake from a diversity of views.
I, along with dozens of my fellow religious leaders throughout the Pittsburgh area, strongly oppose the movement known as “White Christian Nationalism” and all those who advocate for it. The principles of this movement are antithetical to our own religious faiths and our role as citizens under the US Constitution.
It claims that our country was explicitly founded as a Christian nation. It “assumes that being Christian is the standard of American life, and everything else or everyone else is a deviation from that,” according to Brock Bahler, Senior Lecturer in Religious Studies at the University of Pittsburgh.
A statement issued last year by the National Council of Churches characterized Christian nationalism by its religious affirmations. They are (quoting from the statement):
• that the United States was founded as a Christian nation;
• that America is exceptional. That is, God has given the United States particular blessings and privileges not available to people in other countries, and the nation must remain Christian in order for those blessings to continue;
Read More
• that only Christians are the proper custodians of this nation’s heritage;
• that Christianity (or a particular form of Christianity) should have privileged status in the United States, particularly in matters of law and political policy;
• that, even when their presence is tolerated, people who practice other religions or none cannot be fully American — they are not welcomed, their voices are discounted, and they are not to be trusted with political and cultural leadership;
• that Christians in general and some Christians in particular should enjoy a level of legal protection not granted to those who practice other religions; and,
• that Christians have been made to suffer unjustly, leaving them no alternative but to respond with revolutionary zeal to preserve the United States as a great Christian nation.
All of these positions are at odds with our country’s founding and subsequent history. These beliefs have caused their supporters to spew hate and commit violence against Blacks, Jews, Muslims, Hindus and Christians who disagree with them because they deem these groups to be anti-American and anti-Christian.
White Christian Nationalists have attacked minorities repeatedly in recent years. The murderer in the Tree of Life/Or l’Simcha-Dor Hadash-New Light synagogue massacre in October 2018, was motivated by these ideas.
The founding fathers were God-fearing and enlightened enough to understand the peril of religious intolerance and religious violence. It is not debatable that our nation’s founders refused to install a state religion to prevent government from enforcing religion on any of America’s citizens or residents.
White Christian Nationalism is a direct threat to the physical safety and spiritual well-being of the vast majority of Pennsylvanians who do not believe as they do.
We will work tirelessly in interfaith and inter-racial coalition to defeat any candidate for any public office who promotes these views directly or indirectly. We will call out and defeat any attempt to hide behind “dog whistles” or “plausible deniability”. White Christian Nationalism is a danger to the lives of Pennsylvanians and a clear threat to our democracy. We and our communities will oppose it and its adherents with all of our faith and strength. We have unwavering appreciation for religious freedom and our great Commonwealth.
I am a proud representative of Pittsburgh Jews United Against Extremism, a grassroots group of concerned citizens. If you would like to encourage your community to stand with us against extremism, here are some action items we recommend:
First, use your voice to educate your community about the dangers of extremism. Please feel free to use my words above in any communications.
Second, the surest way to make sure that extremism doesn’t win is to persuade everyone to vote. We have partnered with “The New PA Project,” a nonpartisan Get Out The Vote organization that encourages civic participation in traditionally marginalized communities across Pennsylvania. Please consider working with them to plan community events or to coordinate efforts for door knocking or phone banking in your neighborhood.
Last, please consider creating or encouraging groups of concerned citizens in your neighborhood to build an independent movement against extremism.
Jamie Gibson, rabbi emeritus of Temple Sinai in Pittsburgh, is a senior rabbinic fellow in the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem and is the Rabbi Jason Z. Edelstein lecturer in Catholic-Jewish Dialogue at St. Vincent College. He asks readers to write Pittsburgh Jews United Against Extremism for help in organizing against extremism.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.