This article is one of a series of opinion pieces the Post-Gazette will be running until the election, addressing the issues at stake from a diversity of views.
Doug Mastriano, the Republican candidate for governor, only takes questions from reporters who won't challenge him on his extreme views. That’s troubling.
It’s troubling because voters have a right to hear answers to questions that he may not want to address. For example, he says we live in a Christian nation, and he sees no need for a separation of church and state. That's provocative, but our nation has always believed in the rule of law so that it can be applied fairly to people of all faiths, or people who practice no religion at all. Although he wants to violate this important principle, Mr. Mastriano won't talk to reporters about it. Why not?
As governor, he says he would sign legislation to ban abortion after only six weeks, without exception for incest, rape or a medical emergency that would put the mother’s life at risk if she continued to carry a child. He should answer questions about this. What, for example, does Mr. Mastriano say to children who have been raped? Should a woman be forced to give birth to an attacker’s child?
Doug Mastriano would be better served if he would venture outside his tiny world of Christian nationalists to talk about the issues, but so far, he has refused. This “run and hide” tactic leads to serious questions about how he would govern if he were elected.
There are other questions that ought to be answered. For example, he claims to support election integrity but, as a denier of the 2020 election results, it's a fair question to ask: Would he appoint a biased secretary of state who would only selectively count the votes?
Read More
We can all support the need to have reliable elections, and fraudulent voter registrations should be wiped off the roles. But he needs to answer this: Where's his evidence that there has been fraud? Why would Mr. Mastriano force people to re-register, and what does he say to critics who say his plan unfairly targets Black and brown voters? These are fair questions, and he should grant interviews with mainstream media outlets.
We learn from others when we hear opposing points of view. Where is the evidence that Doug Mastriano will listen to anyone outside of his tight circle of true believers and friends? Where is the evidence that he will hear the concerns of people who don't look like him or think like him? What does he have to say to Jews, to Muslims, or people who don't believe in God?
Astonishingly, Mr. Mastriano paid $5,000 to Gab Social to help promote his campaign, and he accepted the endorsement of Gab’s founder. (He later removed his account and said he rejected anti-semitism.)
Robert Bowers, who awaits trial for the Tree of Life massacre, used Gab Social prior to the shootings to call worshipers “children of Satan” before entering the synagogue to kill them. Gab Social also posts commentary by David Duke, a former leader of the Ku Klux Klan, and Alex Jones, the disgraced liar who claimed the murder of little children in Sandy Hook was a hoax staged by the government. Why, reporters would like to ask, would Doug Mastriano have aligned himself with such a site?
Perhaps the problem is that Mr. Mastriano can only speak to his inner circle because he really hasn't thought through the consequences of his radical ideas. He wants, for example, to abolish property taxes as a way of financing public education. But teachers’ unions and supporters of strong public schools say Mr. Mastriano would wreck the public education system by destroying the means to fund it.
He would give state money to religious schools, he says, but does the government have the right to impose educational standards on private institutions? Would private schools agree to administer student achievement tests? If not, are we ready to pay tax dollars to institutions that won't measure and report their students' progress?
Before he merits your vote, Doug Mastriano needs to answer questions to show how he would treat people who don't believe in his intolerant brand of conservative Christian nationalism.
He's got radical ideas. But are they good ideas? He won't engage his critics, perhaps, because his extreme ideas, once challenged, would fall apart.
Alan Guenther is a Quaker who lives in the Bloomfield section of Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Doug Mastriano posts with bigots on Gab Social. Voters should know.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.