Coming into this week’s two game series with Pittsburgh, Yankee slugger Aaron Judge had hit 59 home runs, and with one more he would tie Babe Ruth’s record, set in 1927. With two more he would tie Roger Maris’s record of 61, set in 1961.

And with three more, he would set the American League record and, arguably, a new “true” or “clean” MLB record. What he endured to set the record offers a lesson in the world then and now. Technology has brought advantages but also disadvantages.

The Roger Maris record of 61 stood for 37 years until the steroid era. Sluggers Mark McGwire, Sammy Sosa and then ex-Pirate Barry Bonds, all of the National League, had 60-plus HR seasons in the 1998 to 2001 period.

Many baseball purists, however, regard the “true home run record” — that’s not tainted by performance-enhancing drugs — to be the Ruth and Maris marks of 60 and 61. And that’s why Judge — the likable and modest 6-foot-7, 282-pound outfielder — has created so much excitement and media attention.

Advertise with us

But first, how do the Pirates’ records compare? There have been some famous home runs in Pirate baseball history — Bill Mazeroski’s 1960 World Series winning bottom-of-the-ninth shot being perhaps the most dramatic of all time. Pirate fans may pine for their own home run king.

In years past, we had one in Ralph Kiner, who lead the league from 1946 to 1952 and come close to the record with 51 home runs in 1947 and closer with 54 in 1949. Willie Stargell hit 48 home runs in 1971 and 44 in 1973 — good numbers but not close to the record. No one, sadly, has done that well since. The top five Pirate home run leaders of all time are: Willie Stargell with 475, Ralph Kiner with 301, Roberto Clemente with 240, Andrew McCutchen with 203, and Barry Bonds with 176.

Back in 1961, there was a home run race between Maris and his more famous Yankee teammate, Mickey Mantle. The pair put on quite a home run clinic, battling back and forth for the lead until Mantle, then with 54, was sidelined with a hip injury near the end of the season. Maris then pulled away and went on to top Ruth’s record, hitting No. 61 on the very last day of the season.

But Maris, unlike the outgoing Mantle, was reserved, a nice guy but not a fan favorite. The press hounded him about the record and wrote unfairly about him. At one point, clumps of his hair started falling out.

In those days, players didn’t have the media advisors and handlers stars have today. Still, Maris prevailed and set the record.

Advertise with us

Judge, in today’s baseball world, is a different story. First, the press love him. He is an overwhelming fan favorite. But Judge has had a different set of pressures that flow from the rigors of the modern game and its analytics.

According to analyst Mike Petriello, Judge has faced more pitchers than either Ruth or Maris faced in their day. Ruth faced 67 pitchers in 1927, Maris 101 pitchers in 1961. They saw the same pitcher for more innings than hitters today, giving them the advantage of familiarity. Judge will likely face more than 240 pitchers this season.

Pitching today is a much more sophisticated business, as pitchers go fewer innings and have more data-assisted training with pitch types, placement, batter analytics, etc.. Pitching speeds are also up. Fresh relievers with blazing fastballs are used routinely and sometimes in early innings.

Today’s technical assistance and data analysis come to hitters as well as pitchers. But the advantage now seems to rest with pitching.

The two games with Pittsburgh saw one record tied. In the first game, a young Pittsburgh flame-thrower named Luis Ortiz held the Yanks at bay while Bryan Reynolds (4-for-5 with a homer) and others helped the Bucs to an 8-4 lead. But in the ninth inning, the Yanks exploded for 5 runs and won, 9-8. Most importantly, Judge hit his 60th home run — a 430- foot solo shot into the left field bleachers — tying Babe Ruth.

Advertise with us

In the second game, the Yankees won 14-2, but Judge didn’t tie Maris. He doubled twice, struck out and walked.

Judge has 12 games to go. As I write this, he has 60 HRs and 128 RBIs, with a batting average of .316, making him a contender for the Triple Crown (only 10 players in history have won it) and American League MVP. He also currently leads the American League in on-base percentage (.419), slugging percentage (.703), and on-base plus slugging (1.122). It’ll be a season for the ages.

As for the Bucs, who knows what rising young talents may once again put Pittsburgh back in the home run competition?

Jack Doyle publishes a popular history website The Pop History Dig. He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Sixty years ago, Pittsburgh's Rachel Carson was more right than she knew.”