“IS THIS heaven?”

“No, it’s Iowa.”

“Well, it looks like hell.”

I’m guessing that would be the reaction of Shoeless Joe Jackson and the ghosts of other ballplayers emerging from the corn field in Dyersville, Iowa, after they get a look at what greed may soon transform.

Advertise with us

Few among us are not familiar with one of the best baseball movies ever made, “Field of Dreams,” the emotional story of connection between father and son and an iconic real-life baseball field carved into a cornfield on the outskirts of a tiny Iowa village. The little ballfield, a small souvenir stand, and the farmhouse still draw thousands of visitors to the site every year, despite its remote location, but the charm may soon disappear into the corn forever.

According to the Des Moines Register, public officials in eastern Iowa have put together a plan to develop the complex, including a 3,000-seat stadium that will cost an estimated $50 million, with up to $45 million of that coming from the taxpayers.

That’s just the ballpark.

An outfit called Go the Distance, which owns the movie site, is apparently going all in to spend another $80 million to develop the area surrounding the stadium. Go the Distance is a development group led by Hall of Famer Frank Thomas. It wants to build nine baseball and softball fields, dormitories, a fieldhouse, walking trails, an RV park, an amphitheater, and a 104-room hotel.

Oh, and a fishing pond.

Advertise with us

Anyone who has made the trek to the Field of Dreams site can attest to the magic, especially in the summer when the corn is high. The site is truly rural. Corn is everywhere. You drive down a narrow country road to get there, you park in a dusty lot, and you get your first glimpse of what Kevin Costner, as Ray Kinsella, saw.

You imagine the voice out there somewhere: “Build it and he will come.”

What a treat it was to meet the man who owned Field of Dreams at the time, Don Lansing. During my visit, he spent most of his day puttering around the site on his garden tractor. Mr. Lansing stopped what he was doing to talk about his love for the place. He even signed a ball for me.

Then it was time to take the field. A friend of mine, retired Toledo firefighter Bob Curtis, and I put on our best vintage baseball jerseys and had a “catch” on the diamond.

That’s part of the beauty of the place. Fans can play on the field. We even emerged from the corn while our wives took videos.

Advertise with us

Now all that nostalgia is in jeopardy.

We should have seen this coming when Mr. Lansing sold the Field of Dreams in 2012. Not long after the sale, a plan to build additional ballfields began moving forward. Though challenged all the way to the Iowa Supreme Court, the plan was ultimately approved.

So it seems that one day we will be looking at a theme park, not an iconic movie site or a place of reverence. How far is this going to go? How about a Doubleheader Roller Coaster? You know, one that turns you upside down twice. Or maybe a haunted house with wax figures of famous ballplayers?

I reached out to urban planner and former Toledoan Michael Young, who now lives in San Diego, for his take on the scheme. His take is not pretty. “What a dirty rotten shame,” he said. “Every single thing that made the site alluring and attractive will be forever lost. What they will have will be just another amateur sports complex.”

If he were the county planner for the Dyersville area, he added, he would have pushed to designate a one-mile-wide buffer zone as agricultural zoning around the ballfield, protecting it and the corn crop into perpetuity. Such an effort would have no doubt gotten him fired, he noted.

Advertise with us

Dyersville is not a whole lot bigger than another town that’s a shrine of baseball — Cooperstown, N.Y., home of the baseball Hall of Fame and Doubleday Field. Yet Doubleday is not surrounded by auxiliary baseball fields and luxury hotels. In fact, getting a room there in the summer can be a challenge.

I love the fact that Major League Baseball plays one regular-season game at a temporary ballpark at the Field of Dreams. Last year’s inaugural event was a stunning success. Why can’t we just leave well enough alone?

The Field of Dreams will never be the same if this plan goes forward. Instead of knuckleballs, we get knuckleheads.

No hits, no runs, and one very costly error.

Thomas Walton is the retired editor and vice president of The Blade of Toledo. Contact him at: twalton@theblade.com.