This was the night, the night of Aug. 7, the night that never should have happened, 15 years ago tonight. Fifteen years is but a burp in the arc of history, but 2007 has done a thoroughly admirable job of vanishing into deep cultural ghostliness. It might take Google less than a second, but for a lot of us, it takes a muscled scrubbing of the memory even to dislodge some of that year’s more conspicuous milestones and atrocities.
NASA launched the Phoenix Mars Lander, a gunman slaughtered 32 people at Virginia Tech, Rudy Giuliani was a candidate for president, and so was Joe Biden. On the night that never should have happened, baseball was the stage for what could have been an uninhibited celebration of American history and cultural tradition, as Barry Lamar Bonds walked his menacing aura into a batter's box in San Francisco.
A classical Giants’ slugger and a former Pirates top draft pick and their National League MVP another 15 years before that night, Bonds stood just one swoop of his fearsome lumber from becoming the Major Leagues’ all-time Home Run King, a title that had changed hands exactly one time in the previous 100 years.
All Bonds needed was a nice, lunchable, launchable pitch from someone named Mike Bacsik of the Washington Nationals, that and the temerity to step past Hank Aaron into immortality, and, of course, he got it, and he launched it 430-some feet into the California night.
Do you remember that night? Remember where you were? What you thought? What was said? Did you feel it in your baseball heart?
Me neither, and that’s a sad deal.
Read More
On the Crystal Anniversary of Bond’s 756th homer, the one that erased Aaron’s record of 755 that stood 33 years, there are, ironically, too few aspects that are crystalline or perfectly transparent about it.
At the root of our confliction are the origin stories of the two men, as you could scarcely invent two American baseball players more different than Aaron and Bonds. One became revered and the other reviled; one was elected to the Hall of Fame on the first ballot and the other denied entry all 10 years he appeared on it, one was an almost mythical figure and the other was all too real.
Aaron came to baseball with advantages that totaled less than zero. Born into poverty in Alabama, his basic idea of baseball was smacking stones with a stick. When someone finally got a bat into his hands, he held it incorrectly, cross-handed. When he climbed aboard the train that extricated him from Mobile to join the Indianapolis Crowns of the Negro Leagues in the early ‘50s, he had $2.50 in his pocket, all that his mother had to give him.
Bonds grew up in San Mateo County, California, just south of San Francisco, but more specifically, he grew up in the Major League clubhouses frequented by his father, the talented but well-traveled outfielder Bobby Bonds. Barry was a baseball prodigy, never wanting for anything, including swagger.
Not surprisingly then, Aaron and Bonds’ appointments with history came at the diametrically opposite edges of narrative theater, one as high drama and the other as low comedy, though some would say tragedy.
What Aaron overcame the night of April 8, 1974, when he surpassed Babe Ruth’s all-time home run record of 714, took more than merely decades of staggering accomplishment. Yes, he’d transformed himself into literally a Ruthian figure on the field, but the social tradeoff was so toxic that the Atlanta Journal, in its preparation for that historic night, secretly prepared his obituary in case Aaron got murdered for his trouble.
This wasn’t the kind of grinding Deep South racism Aaron had known all his life. It was the hot manifestation of hateful outrage that a Black man would erase the game’s most hallowed record.
Even less surprisingly, the Hall of Fame broadcaster Vin Scully, who died this week at 94, was perfectly ready for Aaron’s moment.
For a full 26 seconds after describing a pitch from Dodgers’ lefty Al Downing that Aaron rifled into the Braves bullpen, Scully let the crowd swell and roar and rock to his silence, until he finally said, “What a marvelous moment for baseball; what a marvelous moment for Atlanta and the state of Georgia; what a marvelous moment for the country and the world. A black man is getting a standing ovation in the Deep South for breaking a record of an all-time baseball idol. And it is a great moment for all of us, and particularly for Henry Aaron ... And for the first time in a long time, that poker face in Aaron shows the tremendous strain and relief of what it must have been like to live with for the past several months.
“It is over, at 10 minutes after 9 in Atlanta, Georgia, Henry Aaron has eclipsed the mark set by Babe Ruth.”
By the night of the Bonds eclipse in 2007, the game and any romanticism if engendered within the American soul was nearing at the tail end of the steroid era, a ruinous period that had begun in the late ‘80s. It was not Bonds’ fault entirely that his moment was splattered by the stain of performance enhancing drugs, but enough of it was, and the timing was dreadful — it was post Congress, two years after the Congressional hearing at which a pantheon of sluggers got called on the carpet to illuminate the game’s steroid problem. None looked more guilty than Mark McGwire.
“I’m not here to talk about the past,” the Cardinals masher said infamously when asked pointedly about his PED use.
It was McGwire, who broke baseball’s single season home run record by stroking 70 in 1998, who triggered the downfall of Bonds. Incensed at special arrangements made to handle the national media who magnetized to the batting cage to watch McGwire in Bonds’ home stadium, Bonds thought maybe he’d let everybody see what he could do with McGwire’s pharmaceutical advantages.
Three years later, despite never hitting 50 homers in any of his first 15 seasons, Bonds hit 73.
Maybe something was up?
In his mid-30’s, he head grew. His feet grew. Still officially described as 6-1, 185 on Baseballreference.com, the Giants roster in 2007 listed him at 6-1, 240.
He became a central figure in the Balco scandal, named for the Bay area lab that produced supposedly undetectable steroids trafficked by, among others, Bonds’ personal trainer, Greg Anderson.
The homers kept flying, another 180 of them after the summer when he turned 37. Of those, it was No. 173 that flew on the night that never should have happened. To pass Aaron then, Bonds overcome nothing so much as his own legendary peevishness.
It was a moment so significant that the Commissioner of Baseball, Bud Selig, did not show up for it. Selig, who spent the bulk of the steroid era with his head in the sand, hoping nobody would get close to his beloved Aaron, simply couldn’t stand to watch.
Aaron, who died in January of 2021 and was on record saying he thoughts Bonds belonged in the Hall of Fame, also testified to Congress about steroids.
Asked directly by the late Senator John McCain what baseball should do about records attained through chemical enhancement, said with his reliable grace, “That’s up to baseball.”
That’s what it sounds like when someone cares more about the game than about himself.
Aaron hit 755 homers. I’m not sure how many Bonds hit. I guess I could Google it.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.