In Egypt, the price of flatbread is fixed and more than half the population lives on loaves costing just 0.05 Egyptian pounds (0.25 cents), thanks to heavy government support. Alms for the needy are one of the oldest forms of charity. The tradition persists to this day, in the form of food stamps in the U.S., food banks in the UK, free school meals in Japan, direct subsidy programs like Egypt's, and India's price controls on farm produce. On top of that, many countries exempt essential ingredients from sales taxes.

With nearly 800 million people — about a 10th of the world's population — unable to feed themselves adequately last year, you might expect this form of welfare to be growing in size and significance.

In fact, it's close to the opposite. Food is largely subsidized not for the world's poorest people, who are most at risk of hunger, but for its richest and most amply fed. The funds that are spent go overwhelmingly to farmers rather than the hungry. And while much of that helps to increase the supply of food, hundreds of billions of dollars are doing the opposite, reducing the amount of nutrition available to feed the world.

A recent report by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization breaks it down. Subsidies direct to consumers — especially if targeted at those most in need — are one of the most effective ways of tackling hunger. But they're a small part of total global support. Just $72 billion out of $630 billion is dedicated to the food and farming sector worldwide.

Advertise with us

What's more, they're skewed toward people in high-income countries who are least at risk of going short. In the richest nations, 4.6% of the value of agricultural output comprises consumer subsidies. In the poorest ones, the figure is 0.6%.

Far more important is what's given to farmers. Some $244 billion goes to farmers. Again, this money is largely going to rich countries, which provide producers with incentives equivalent to 24% of output. That figure falls to 16% in upper-middle income countries such as China and Brazil.

In less affluent nations, export bans, tariffs and other market interventions intended to reduce costs to local consumers often have the opposite effect. They act as a tax on output and discouraging farmers from growing sufficient produce. Those measures increase the cost of production by 4% in lower-middle income countries such as India, rising to 9% in low income countries like those in sub-Saharan Africa.

Unpicking this mess will be challenging. As anyone who has watched the politics of the US Farm Bills and the EU Common Agricultural Policy knows, once support for agriculture is established it is hard to dismantle. Changes to such a heavily subsidized sector inevitably involve wrenching losses of income in rural areas, which are often over-represented in legislatures. Path dependency is hard to break.

In many developing countries, it's not even clear that cheaper food is always the government’s main objective. When the poorest people in your country are farm workers, any drive to reduce the cost of nutrition risks lowering incomes at the bottom.

Advertise with us

The political risks of hurting the rural lower-middle class are even greater, given their propensity for political action. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's attempt to unpick his country's mandi system, whereby the government bought produce at fixed prices through its own marketing yards. This resulted in more than a year of protests before Modi abandoned the proposal. Farmers feared that the benefits of a free market in food would accrue mostly to traders, and preferred to stick with the status quo.

The world is facing multiple challenges in feeding itself as its population grows toward 11.2 billion in 2100 and climate change degrades and reduces the area available to farm. Alongside the rising burden of hunger is a tide of obesity that's stalking poor countries. That's due in part to the fact that calories from fats and sugar are cheaper to produce than those from cereals or healthy vegetables, a situation that itself is related to the way food subsidies favor some crops over others.

Something has to change. If governments facing fiscal strain from the aftermath of the covid-19 pandemic want to do something about the food crisis that's come in its wake, they could do worse than look at the way their own spending is exacerbating the problem.

David Fickling is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist.