Why would Donald Trump find it difficult to say “yesterday”? After all, it’s not a word most find challenging to utter. Among the videos aired during the latest session of the Jan. 6 Committee was raw footage of Trump taping a public message the morning after the U.S. Capitol was violently breached.
In clip after clip we see the ostensibly telegenic natural stumbling over reading from a teleprompter, pounding his podium in frustration, and quibbling with his daughter, Ivanka, who can be overheard coaxing and coaching him in the background.
Trump enthusiasts may consider him a brave, unvarnished truth-teller, but he has always been layered in artifice — from his bleached, coiffed hair and heavy carrot-hued makeup, to how he scripted and choreographed his presidency as if the White House was merely the backdrop for the four-year run of a reality TV show. Still, the day following the attack he was rattled enough to drag out the recording of a three-minute video for more than an hour.
Unable to contain his irritation at being compelled to issue a critical statement, Trump behaved as if he had been lugged to the presidential podium. As the committee made clear, he didn’t intervene on Jan. 6 because the mob was composed of his supporters, following his directives. It’s also understandable why he deleted a sentence stating that the election was over from the prepared speech. He could not admit that he and his voters were not “victims,” that the “steal” they sought to expose was a big lie.
But there was one word he also insisted on striking which is, frankly, striking. “’Yesterday’ is a hard word for me,” he complains. “Take the word ‘yesterday’ out because it doesn't work.” Why might the man who promised to take us back in time, to the fabled era when America was “great,” have trouble with saying “yesterday”?
Less a Freudian slip than a poker tell, Trump’s struggle with this simple word provides insight into “Trump-time” — not just yesterday but all things past. Scholars have associated Trump’s brand of authoritarian populism with the politics of nostalgia, an effort to resurrect a mythic American past of imperial might and hegemonic masculinity. However, it is not his attachment to some glorious, imagined past that is the key to the regressive politics he enables and mobilizes.
Certainly the facts of “yesterday” and all yesterdays — the precise progression of events — are antithetical to his thinking. In contrast, the aim of the Jan. 6 committee’s primetime session was to address a matter of time in order to demonstrate how timing matters. For more than three hours, Trump sat in the private White House dining room watching the attack unfold; impervious to pleas from his advisers, staff and family to tamper the flames of the violence he had ignited.
The committee’s televised hearing was riveting because it put on display a minute-by-minute account of what we already knew. “President Trump did not fail to act during the 187 minutes between leaving the Ellipse and telling the mob to go home,” Rep. Kinzinger charged. “He chose not to act."
Trump has a troubled relationship with the past, from his fabricated stories about his family’s genealogy to the whitewashing of American history that he and his cronies promoted in the 1776 Project, which continues to provoke fraught debates over curriculum in schools. After several famous gaffes — suggesting that Frederick Douglass, the 19th century Black abolitionist, was still alive or blaming Canada for the British troops’ burning of the White House in 1814 — Trump’s historical illiteracy is well known.
More importantly, Trump-time is a back-to-the-future chronoception that projects apprehensions about the future onto the present and the past. He and his followers are not driven by hope and dreams of a better tomorrow. Feeling vulnerable because of challenges to entitlements and privileges born by social hierarchies, they embrace even greater apocalyptic fears about displacement, replacement, and national decay.
Yesterday “doesn’t work,” nor does today or even tomorrow in Trump’s prospective time-warp. Unbounded by material reality and historical fact, thought and judgment are impossible. If we want Trump to be history we need to understand how Trump-time promotes a timeless fantasy of invulnerability, replacing facts, chronology, and historicity with a perception of victimhood that is both concrete (“the lie”) and transhistorical.
Alyson Cole is professor of political science at Queens College and The Graduate Center, City University of New York.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.