“One of the biggest threats to our elections and to democracy in general is misinformation and disinformation. Whether intentional or unintentional, both reduce voters’ confidence in the electoral process, and in turn, discourage participation,” acting Pennsylvania Secretary of State Leigh M. Chapman testified in the U.S. Senate.
Ms. Chapman is right. Disinformation poses the greatest threat to trust in this year’s midterm elections. Elections are an easy target for malign actors — both foreign and domestic — looking to harm American democracy. From lawsuits over the proper certification of election results to state laws that prevent the pre-canvassing of ballots and slow the tabulation of election results, the intricacies of election administration present great opportunity for anyone looking to undermine Pennsylvanians’ confidence in the system.
In the overwhelming majority of cases, election officials do their job flawlessly. But there are actors who seize opportunities to enflame partisan tensions and encourage distrust of the system and each other.
Pennsylvanians should be clear-eyed about information they are consuming, understand how information operations work and consider why they are being targeted.
There are obvious political reasons why domestic actors might manipulate information to undermine confidence in election results. A recent study at the University of Washington identified “over 49 million tweets connected to 456 distinct misinformation stories spread about the 2020 U.S. election” in a three-month span alone. While most of these stories supported President Trump’s claims of election fraud, some were also promoted by supporters of President Biden. In short, zealots and paid provocateurs will distort information to serve their own ends, regardless of the effect on American democracy.
Pennsylvanians also face attempts by foreign actors to sow chaos in U.S. democracy. Russia’s sordid interference in the 2016 presidential election is well-documented. Not only did Russian state-sponsored hackers unsuccessfully attempt to penetrate Pennsylvania’s voter registration databases, but Russian government trolls also targeted Pennsylvanians through Facebook ads and organized pro-Trump rallies in the state. During the 2020 election, Iranian state-sponsored hackers tried to intimidate at least 100,000 registered Democratic voters in Pennsylvania and other states by posing as the members of the far-right Proud Boys and sending messages that threatened physical violence if the recipient did not vote for Trump.
Read More
The U.S. government believes Russia and Iran could try again to interfere in the 2022 midterms. Russia has a keen interest in a distracted America as it seeks to impose its will on Ukraine, and an America consumed by its own electoral strife may be less concerned about providing arms to the Ukrainian military. Across the Middle East, in countries like Iraq, Syria, and Yemen, Iran and the United States are increasingly in confrontation. A preoccupied United States may cede influence in this crucial region to Iran, with implications for national, regional and global security.
While the U.S. government does not believe China interfered in the 2020 U.S. election, the intelligence community has issued warnings of China’s campaigns to influence state and local leaders. Sharp disagreements between the two nations over Taiwan, as well as China’s determined interest in supplanting the United States as the global superpower means Beijing stands to benefit from undermining American democracy.
The success or failure of malign information campaigns this election year depends, in large part, on you. It’s on every voter to find trusted sources for news — when it comes to voting information and election security, those sources should include your local and state election officials. It is their job to present election-related information factually, rather than to make voters mad, sad or outraged. Malign actors who target Pennsylvanians with information campaigns manipulate their targets by using highly emotional (and often untrue) content. Share your political opinions, but make sure you know who is pushing the information you are sharing.
Despite the plethora of information threats, Pennsylvanians should take comfort knowing elections in the state are by and large conducted without issue. The state’s 67 counties all have up-to-date voting systems that produce voter-verifiable paper records that meet current security, auditability, and accessibility standards. Every county is now required to conduct a post-election risk-limiting audit that uses statistical procedures to confirm election results and detect possible fraud and interference from hostile actors. These procedures are in place precisely to ensure that even in the event of a cyberattack on voting systems by a hostile foreign government, the integrity of the vote can be maintained.
In today’s oversaturated and fragmented political media, it’s easy to get only part of the story. Pennsylvanians should have confidence in how the state’s elections are conducted, despite attempts to manipulate information to convince them otherwise — and bring a healthy dose of skepticism to any unusual storylines around election process.
Rachael Dean Wilson is the head of external affairs at the Alliance for Securing Democracy (ASD). David Salvo is the deputy director of the Alliance for Securing Democracy (ASD) and a senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund of the United States (GMF).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.