Last week brought welcome good news for self-government.
The bi-partisan Senate compromise package on guns is not enough, but it is a good start. It emphasizes school safety and mental health and to a limited degree restricts access to guns to the young and the demonstrably unstable.
There was a prime time debate between Lindsey Graham and Bernie Sanders, which educated and enlightened. Why did Sanders win? Substance and the merits. Whereas Mr. Graham used generalities and labels, Mr. Sanders used facts and logic. I hope I have half his fire and brainpower when I’m 80.
And the special House committee to investigate January 6, 2021 continued its hearings, essentially led by Republican Liz Cheney. Ms. Cheney focuses like a laser but is dispassionate. She proves Hume’s axiom that justice is “the cool virtue.”
But I think some Democrats, including at least one on the committee, Adam Schiff, have taken their eye off the prize and jeopardized what could be the great benefit of the committee.
The prize in this instance is not Donald Trump in the clink, or Donald Trump disgraced, or Donald Trump in financial ruin.
The first will not happen. The second would be redundant and would discourage neither Mr. Trump nor his hard-core followers. The third he would somehow dodge.
No, the goal of the committee is not personal, but civic. The prize is to restore some health to our republic, our representative democratic system. And it has three aspects: Truth, clarity and accountability.
The country needs to learn the unvarnished truth of what happened on January 6, and in the days that led up to it. It needs clarity about that truth. And it needs to be clear about who was responsible.
In our system, we hold our politicians accountable primarily through elections, not by criminalizing political opposition.
Otherwise, we have an abusive system of power as its own justification, and not a system of checks, balances, law and limits. Otherwise, we have a banana republic not a republic of laws.
“Lock her up,” was always a chant, and an implied promise, as pernicious and harmful to the system and the country as it was demagogic.
It was also the expression of a political form of hate.
So, too, with the ardent sentiment to prosecute Mr. Trump, for something — anything.
Trump hate is still hate.
It answers Trumpistic hate — for all are not like minded chest thumpers — with more hate — for all who are seen as beneath or below.
And it’s a distraction, because it will get in the way of truth, clarity and responsibility, and bringing those things to all of the country.
Much has been written comparing these hearings with the famous Senate Watergate hearings. The reason those hearings succeeded is that members of the Senate Watergate committee, partisan politicians though they were, managed to rise above partisanship. They knew the goal was to educate, not prosecute.
They had a sense of the elevated stakes. They didn’t want the country to be torn further asunder.
So, all of the players of the time — the committee chairman Sam Ervin, the ranking (Republican) member Howard Baker, the Speaker of the House Carl Albert, the House majority leader Tip O’Neill, and the House Judiciary chairman Peter Rodino — were careful. They were keenly aware of their constitutional and patriotic duties.
They knew the point was to help the nation get through its “long national nightmare,” to use Gerald Ford’s phrase.
Did you know that Mr. Ford might have become president even if Richard Nixon had not nominated him for the vacant vice presidency? That’s because when the veepship was empty, Mr. Albert, who was next in the line of presidential succession, thought of resigning as Speaker so a Democratic House could elect Republican leader Ford as Speaker. Why? Because he felt that if Mr. Nixon was removed, it should not be perceived as just a way to install a Democrat as president.
Such a clear sense of the greater good of the country is much rarer today.
This is why Ms. Cheney is so important. And it is why Adam Schiff is so wrong. She is seeking the higher ground of the patriot. He wants a kill.
Two footnotes:
Responsible Republicans played a central role in the Watergate process which I would describe as: Truth then healing. Two true patriots — the father of modern libertarian Republicanism, Barry Goldwater, and a pipe smoking moderate Republican from Pennsylvania, GOP leader Hugh Scott — were the ones who finally went to Mr. Nixon and told him his support within the party had collapsed. Today, patriotic Republicans, like Rob Portman, Pat Toomey and Mitt Romney could make a huge difference if, after the Jan. 6 committee’s work is complete, they speak out and tell their party: Time to move on from Donald Trump.
Second, the whole Trump end-of-term fiasco makes me think, again, that the British system of making the leader of the majority party in the House of Commons the chief executive affords a cleaner way to remove a chief executive than impeachment: When confidence and support are gone, so is the leader. It could not work here because of separation of powers. But impeachment is too high a bar.
We ought to be able to remove a president for something less than “high crimes and misdemeanors.” We ought to be able to remove a president because he has royally screwed up his term and his office — or lost his damn mind.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.