On Tuesday, Pennsylvania Republicans chose Doug Mastriano as their candidate for governor, and the senate race is still too close to call. Winning the governor’s race would give the party unified control of the state government. Winning the Senate seat, now held by a Republican, could mean the difference between winning and losing the US Senate.
But on Tuesday, the feeling among many Republicans wasn’t excitement, but fear: the concern that primary voters could select candidates too extreme to appeal in November in what remains a competitive and purple state. With no clear frontrunner in either race, polls showed a split field that was likely to elect extreme candidates that were unpopular, even among fellow Republicans.
Wide fields of candidates should give voters more choice, but they don’t. Our primary system can elect a winner with only a small plurality of the vote, leading to candidates that win with just 31% of the vote — and it’s possible to win with even less. Primaries attract a lot of candidates, and usually the more candidates, the lower a percentage of the vote a candidate will need to win.
Mainstream Republicans rightly worried that their party would nominate Senate and gubernatorial candidates widely disliked within their own party — even when 69% of voters preferred someone else. And that these candidates would both lose the crucial elections.
There’s an easy solution: Ranked Choice Voting. It gives voters the power to rank the entire field in order of preference. If no one earns a majority, it sets off a series of instant runoffs until the first candidate with the deepest and broadest support crosses 50%.
Here was the situation on Tuesday. On the gubernatorial side, State Sen. Doug Mastriano — who ran to the right of his eight other rivals — won with under half of the vote. That means that most Republican voters preferred a candidate who was not as divisive. Even conservative groups fear that Mastriano is too extreme, and that he “would get clobbered” in November. Mastriano was at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, and has been subpoenaed by the House commission investigating the insurrection.
Read More
In the days leading up to the election, Republican party leaders attempted a last-ditch effort to consolidate around former Congressman Lou Barletta. But with the ballot already set and thousands of early votes mailed in, it was a case of too little, too late.
On the Senate side, Mehmet Oz and Dave McCormick both have around 31% of the vote, with Oz having a slight lead. If Oz ends up winning, Republicans will have a tough time rallying around him in November. Polling shows that he is viewed unfavorably by a remarkable 46% of GOP primary voters, a number significantly higher than any other candidate.
Whichever candidate wins the Senate race will go into the November general election knowing that nearly 70% of Republicans voted for a different candidate.
This is no way to choose candidates. It’s a math quirk that gives divisive and unpopular candidates a bonus in large fields. It weaponizes what should be a good thing — a choice among candidates — against voters. And there’s an easy way to fix it.
Ranked choice voting solves the plurality problem. It’s the best tool to help voters negotiate crowded fields and express the fullness of their vote. It encourages candidates to talk to everyone and broaden their appeal, rather than courting the base and winning with the intense backing of a loud minority. And it makes it easier for a party to come together after a difficult primary, since there can be no dispute that everyone’s voice was heard.
Many Virginia Republicans actually credit ranked choice voting with determining the strongest nominee, rallying the entire party together afterwards, and making it possible to defeat former Gov. Terry McAuliffe last fall.
Yet Virginia Republicans aren’t the only ones who recognize the value of this nonpartisan fix. Democrats used it in New York City to select a mayoral nominee, Maine uses it for all federal elections, and several western states used it in 2020 during Democratic presidential primaries.
Some states use runoffs to defeat the plurality problem. But runoffs bring different problems: It’s expensive to re-run an election several weeks later, and turnout usually drops well below the primary.
RCV is better, faster and cheaper. Most importantly, it helps produce winners. Virginia Republicans already know this. Pennsylvania Republicans are now learning this — the hard way.
Armin Samii is the Ranked Choice Voting Policy & Research Lead at Voter Choice PA. He lives in Lawrenceville.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.