In the days when big-shot NYC commissioners tooled around town in chauffeured limousines, I first saw Manhattan Borough President Constance Baker Motley in a New York Times photo. The year was 1965, and five years earlier I had learned to read the broadsheet New York Times on a crowded New York City subway as a seventh grader.
By January 1966, Manhattan President Motley was front-page news everywhere as President Lyndon Johnson announced her nomination as the nation’s first black woman federal judge. She would sit for about 40 years, some of them as chief judge, on the bench of the storied Southern District of New York. Recently confirmed U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson named Judge Motley as her inspiration.
Constance Baker Motley was born on Sept. 21, 1921, in New Haven, Conn., the daughter of Caribbean immigrants from Nevis.
Educated at historically Black Fisk University in Nashville and Columbia University Law School in New York, earning a New York University degree in between, CBM was among America’s most successful and distinguished lawyers. As a clerk at the NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund, she helped Thurgood Marshall win the Brown vs. the Board of Education landmark school integration case.
In her own right, CBM argued 10 Supreme Court cases, winning nine.
Readers of a certain age may recall the case of James Meredith. CBM won the legal fight for him to attend the University of Mississippi, where he became the first Black student to enroll in 1962.
During Ms. Jackson’s Senate confirmation hearings, millions of Americans watched Sen. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., demand to know from Judge Brown Jackson, a wife and mother, the definition of a woman. With intelligence and dignity worthy of a Supreme Court nominee, KBJ, a model of propriety, endured the abuse.
Nearly 60 years ago at the judicial confirmation hearing for CBM, one senator demanded to know whether she could be fair to racists and segregationists when considering their cases.
Meanwhile, back then, U.S. Rep. Adam Clayton Powell, the most powerful Black man in Washington, continued his control of Harlem politics, as Tammany Hall boss Carmine DeSapio was still regarded as the leader of the rest of Manhattan’s Democrats.
My childhood address of 1268 Park Ave., at 98th Street, was the clearest sign that one had crossed over from elegant Manhattan into impoverished East Harlem and Harlem. Two years spent as a grocery delivery boy introduced me to the service entrances and kitchens of New York’s finest co-ops, blocks from my home but miles apart economically.
Briefly politically ambitious, I grew up and moved to Harlem’s famed middle-class Riverton Apartments and by 1974 was elected to the New York Democratic County Committee.
Although the committee’s sole duty was to choose the next Tammany Hall boss, I got the associated downtown social and political invitations. Liveried doormen admitted me to the beautiful lobbies of edifices where I used to deliver groceries via the back doors.
One Park Avenue gathering stands out 50 years later. Several Democratic bigwigs were in attendance. That was no big deal. But holding court, as it were, at a table in the dining room was Judge Constance Baker Motley. I gawked, stared, said nothing and left the room, feeling my rightful place was in the back with the help.
CBM was an unsung legend of the civil rights movement. Besides her work on Brown vs. Board alongside Thurgood Marshall, she represented Martin Luther King several times and advised Mississippi civil rights leader Medgar Evers.
He was murdered at his home by an assassin who hid behind a bush she had urged him to cut down.
Upon becoming a politician in 1964, CBM became the first Black woman elected to the New York state Senate. The next year she was elected the first female Manhattan borough president. Five years later Ketanji Brown Jackson was busy being born.
Her hero died in 2005. Thus CBM did not witness first Black Vice President Kamala Harris announce the 53-47 Senate confirmation of Judge Jackson’s ascent to the top of the American judiciary. CBM merely paved the way.
Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.