The second Senate impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump, which is set to begin this week, does not open the door to reaching backward in time to impeach former presidents and public officials for alleged offenses of the distant past, as senators such as John Cornyn and Ted Cruz (Republicans from Texas) have suggested.

Both the Constitution’s language and its broader structure indicate that as long as a president or federal official is impeached by the House of Representatives while he is still in office, the Senate trial can take place after he has left office.

The trial of this former president starting on Tuesday is an easy case. Where the House impeachment occurred while then-President Trump was in office, the Constitution allows that process to be completed in the Senate trial.

Article 1, Section 2, Clause 5 gives the House “the sole power of Impeachment.” The House passed a resolution on Jan. 13, Impeaching then-President Trump for allegedly inciting an insurrection at the Capitol. Article I, Section 3, Clause 6 states that the Senate has the power to try “all” impeachments. After the House legitimately impeached then-President Trump, the text makes clear that the Senate has the power to try that impeachment.

Advertise with us

Moreover, contrary to the dire warning of some Republican senators, going forward with this impeachment trial will not unleash a political parade of horribles that leads to the impeachment trial of former presidents dating back to George Washington. There is nothing in the text of the Constitution that states that a former president or official can be put into a “Back to the Future” DeLorean and transported to a modern-day impeachment proceeding. Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution limits House impeachment to certain sitting public officials. This means that past presidents and ex-public officials cannot be impeached by the House in the first place, a prerequisite to a Senate trial. To the extent Sen. Cornyn, Cruz and others have suggested that proceeding with the Trump trial in the Senate will kick open the door to potential impeachment trials of Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and others for past transgressions, this is fanciful. These past presidents cannot be impeached by the House after their terms in office have expired, so there is no chance of a Senate trial.

Historical practice tracks this textual interpretation. There is not a single case in American history in which a person has been impeached and tried long after they left office. There have been 20 past impeachments. None of these have gone backward in time.

In contrast, there are four prior cases in which the Senate held trials for former officials when the House had initiated impeachment proceedings while the officials were still in office, even though they had resigned or otherwise left the office: Sen. William Blount (1897), Judge West Humphreys (1861), Secretary of War William Belknap (1876) and Judge George English (1926).

In each of these cases, which serve as historical precedent, an impeachment trial has gone forward in the Senate after the individual has left office, but only after the process has been set in motion by the House during the official’s term of office. This gives the Senate the opportunity, as envisioned by the Constitution, to decide what sanction is appropriate for that official. However, there is not a single case in history where the House or Senate has reached back in time, will-nilly, to impeach an official who has served out his term.

This structure of the Constitution makes good sense. Article I, Section 3, Clause 7 states: “Judgment in Cases of Impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust, or Profit under the United States ....” This means the Senate has two separate penalties available once an official is convicted. The first, removal from office, is deemed automatic if the official is convicted. The second, disqualification from holding future office, requires a separate vote of the Senate.

Advertise with us

Three public officials have been impeached, convicted and permanently disqualified from holding future office, all of them federal judges: West Humphreys (1862), Robert Archibald (1912) and Thomas Porteous Jr. (2010). This sanction has an independent purpose in the Constitution.

The whole design of impeachment proceedings, as structured in the Constitution, is to guard against public officials who pose a danger to the state. This is particularly true when the president is charged with an offense. The Framers understood that removing convicted officials was necessary and put that remedy first. However, they were also vigilant enough to recognize that preventing convicted officials from holding future federal office was equally essential, at times, to safeguard the well-being of the nation. That is why the Framers included this separate, discretionary sanction.

A president or high-ranking official cannot commit a serious, impeachable offense toward the end of his term yet dodge the sanctions spelled out by the Framers simply by resigning or turning in the keys to the White House before the Senate can begin its impeachment trial. In the case now about to start in the Capitol, the historical precedent is clear. Regardless of the outcome, the second Senate trial of now-former President Trump is constitutionally permissible. Nor will it create an endless loop of impeachment trials that jeopardize past presidents.

Former President Jimmy Carter — who served in office from 1976 until 1980 and recently turned 96 — is safe from impeachment.

Ken Gormley is president of Duquesne University and a constitutional scholar with expertise on impeachments. He is editor of “The President and the Constitution: A Living History” (NYU Press 2020).