If the text of the U.S. Constitution had a vote, it, too, would have moved forward with a Senate trial in the impeachment of former President Donald Trump, asserted one of the nation's leading constitutional scholars.
Ken Gormley, president of Duquesne University and an expert in constitutional law, said Tuesday that the language of the Constitution without a doubt allows the Senate to try a former president, even if he's no longer in office. Because the House impeached Mr. Trump while he was still an officeholder, "the Constitution says the Senate can try all impeachments" in Article I, Section III, he said.
"It doesn't matter if you do it immediately or if you wait until after the person leaves," Mr. Gormley said. "The Constitution doesn't build in an exception for someone who leaves the office."
A majority of the Senate ultimately agreed with that constitutional argument, voting Tuesday to continue the trial even as Mr. Trump's lawyers argued that the body should not move forward on allegations that he incited the deadly insurrection at the Capitol Jan. 6.
Like the House's impeachment managers earlier Tuesday, Mr. Gormley pointed out that the Constitution allows the Senate to disqualify Mr. Trump from holding office in the future. He said the provision was intended to protect the government from officials who might "endanger the well being of the state" — instituting a political process to remove them, but also to prevent them from running again.
"That meant something," Mr. Gormley said of the future office-holding provision. "It wasn't an accident."
HOW TO WATCH
WHAT: The impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump.
WHEN: The U.S. Senate will begin the trial at noon ET, Wednesday.
WHERE: Proceedings can be viewed on major news networks, including MSNBC, CNN, FOX News, and PBS NewsHour and will be streamed online on several platforms, including C-SPAN. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette livestream will begin at 11:45 a.m.
There is no other clear mechanism to bar someone from holding federal office in the future other than that provision, Mr. Gormley said — and to argue it's unconstitutional to move forward is a stretch.
It wasn’t “totally illogical” to make the argument that Mr. Trump’s lawyers made, Mr. Gormley said, and they had the fact on their side that no president in U.S. history had been tried after leaving office. But that’s a distinction without a difference, he said, because it’s happened to former federal officials.
Like the House’s impeachment managers, Mr. Gormley cited the example of former U.S. Secretary of War William Belknap, who tried to head off impeachment by resigning but was tried eventually. He was acquitted because the Senate couldn’t reach the two-thirds majority to impeach.
What the Constitution doesn’t allow is for the Senate to go back in time and start impeaching other former presidents, such as Barack Obama and Bill Clinton, because “the only way that the Senate trial can legitimately begin after a president has left office is if the House impeached them or began the impeachment proceedings while they were still in office,” Mr. Gormley said.
In this case, Senate Republicans, when they were in the majority before Mr. Trump left office, failed to bring the impeachment articles to their chamber until after President Joe Biden’s inauguration Jan. 20. Their argument now is that a former federal officeholder can’t be tried in the Senate.
Mr. Gormley also criticized the argument made by Mr. Trump’s lawyers that it would take away his right to run for office and the First Amendment right of the American people to vote for him.
“Guess what? There was no First Amendment yet when this impeachment provision was written in the Constitution,” Mr. Gormley said, noting that the Bill of Rights came 10 years later.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.