•
According to the latest Economist/YouGov tracking poll, the majority of Republicans — 53%, say President Donald Trump is a better leader than Abraham Lincoln.
Only 47% of Republicans give Lincoln, the president who led the nation through a civil war that claimed 700,000 lives an edge over a president currently being impeached.
The fact that the standard-bearer of the “party of Lincoln” comes in second in a contest with a shady real-estate mogul and carnival barker isn’t surprising given the party’s de-evolution into a cult of personality.
The fear of Trump and his popularity with the base trumps fidelity to whatever principles the party’s leaders paid lip service to during two terms of Bush and Reagan, but what explains that popularity in the first place?
It’s as if the mysterious black Biofilm that has begun to cover the Lincoln memorial and other DC landmarks became the main attraction instead of the ideas represented by the landmarks themselves.
This is no longer the party of “radical Republicans” who made ending slavery its most important party platform in the early 1860s. Today’s Republicans are not cut from the same cloth as the Republicans who pushed for the ratification of the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments to the Constitution at a time when most white Americans could scarcely conceive of the humanity, much less the citizenship of 4 million newly freed black people.
Lincoln and his Republican allies in the House and Senate did not always agree on tactics, but they were united in their conviction that the American experiment in democracy couldn’t proceed “half slave and half free.”
Those who consider Donald Trump a better president than Abraham Lincoln on any level are not the spiritual descendants of those who tried unsuccessfully to impeach Lincoln’s openly racist vice president and successor, Andrew Johnson as he went about systematically undermining Reconstruction and the rights of black people.
Lincoln’s advisors and Cabinet officials were intellectually serious men. Some were even his most bitter political rivals until they joined the Cabinet, but they set aside their differences with the 16th president because they considered the successful prosecution of the war the only way to preserve the union and end slavery which was already within spitting distance of the 20th century.
Donald Trump’s closest advisors are a motley collection of sycophants, conmen, hustlers and ideologues. Stephen Miller, the cruel architect of Mr. Trump’s immigration policies, is a white supremacist sympathizer and alt-right fan boy as revealed in recently released emails he sent to breitbart.com when he was an aide to Alabama Sen. Jeff Sessions.
The fact that Mr. Miller has been definitively exposed has not endangered his position in the administration in the least. It has not generated calls for his resignation or his firing among Republicans.
The modern GOP is no longer the party of Lincoln, Ulysses S. Grant and Reconstruction. This is the party of Robert E. Lee, whom Mr. Trump praises relentlessly. You would go blind searching for a positive quote or tweet aimed in Grant’s direction by Donald Trump.
So, what are we to make of the 53% of Republicans who declare Lincoln yesterday’s Great Emancipator compared to Donald Trump? Is it possible that Lincoln actually lost points for freeing the slaves with a sizable portion of the crowd that vaulted Trump over him in popularity?
Probably the most charitable take on Mr. Trump’s victory over Lincoln is that the majority of Republicans have no idea who the founder of their party was and have zero interest in that part of the party’s legacy, anyway.
Lincoln and the Radical Republicans are dead. Trump and the modern, far more craven GOP that has distorted its own legacy to better fit into his image, are very much alive.
The voters who fill arenas to cheer on his increasingly unhinged rants believe Mr. Trump is in a position to take their grievances seriously — not because he’s a Republican, but because he’s “one of them.”
When the lens is widened to take in the totality of American voters and not just Republicans, Mr. Trump takes a beating at ‘Honest Abe’s’ hands 75% to 25%.
In a much larger sampling, even Republican presidents Reagan, Nixon and both Bushes score higher than Donald Trump with Democrats and Independents. Donald Trump is, objectively speaking, the least popular president in a century, but his most ardent supporters who get their media from Fox News, don’t know it — or care what those outside the tribe think.
So, when Mr. Trump frequently brags about being “more popular than Lincoln” with the GOP base, he isn’t lying (for once), but he’s not telling the whole truth, either. His base is tiny compared to the larger electorate, but being king of even a tiny hill is something if your stock and trade is ego-based.
Having Donald Trump’s numbers would be soul-crushing for a less narcissistic politician still capable of shame, but apocalyptic leaders are used to playing long odds — and sometimes winning despite those odds.
I have no doubt that Donald Trump could win a second term in 2020 if enough voters in Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin vote the way they did in 2016, or stay home in the same numbers they did then. Will history repeat itself? Probably not. There will be no flirtation with third party candidates this time around, regardless of who the Democratic nominee is.
The more Donald Trump hints at the outbreak of a “civil war” if impeached or denied a second term, the stranger his desire to be favorably compared to Lincoln seems to me.
Lincoln did everything he could to stop the country from unraveling or descending into war, but Mr. Trump is willing to disrupt the delicate balance of all three branches of government to stay in power, even if it ushers in a Constitutional crisis of nightmarish proportions.
Their contrasting political philosophies and actions as presidents obviously don’t stop there, but it is an almost meaningless exercise to list their differences and why they matter.
Unlike Lincoln, the Theater of the Absurd is the only theater Donald Trump is ever going to get caught with his defenses down.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.