Few reputations have undergone the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune as dramatically as President Donald J. Trump in the past month.
It must have gladdened his heart immensely to have topped Abraham Lincoln in a recent survey of Republicans asked to identify the GOP’s greatest leader ever. Mr. Trump beat “Honest Abe” by a considerable margin, making a second look at the current lineup on Mount Rushmore not too ridiculous a prospect for modern Republicans.
During Wednesday’s impeachment vote, Rep. Barry Loudermilk, R-Ga., and Rep. Fred Keller, R-Butler, both invoked Jesus’ crucifixion as the only historical analogy to Mr. Trump’s woes that makes any sense to them or their constituents.
Not to be outdone by his fellow crazy man in the Pennsylvania delegation, Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Pa., compared Mr. Trump’s impeachment to the Japanese sneak attack at Pearl Harbor that resulted in the death of 2,335 military personnel and civilians along with the destruction of a good chunk of America’s Pacific fleet.
For his part, Mr. Trump took a relatively modest route in invoking inappropriate historical analogies in speeches and on Twitter. Instead of comparing himself to Jesus, Mr. Trump declared himself the victim of a modern equivalent of the Salem witch trials.
Tragic irony aside, invoking a historical comparison to women unjustly drowned, hung, torn apart and burned at the stake by a superstitious patriarchy for allegedly being witches is a little more relatable to a MAGA crowd that might find self-aggrandizing allusions to Jesus Christ a wee bit heretical if they really thought it through.
Read More
Still, Mr. Trump couldn’t resist bolstering his bona fides as the Christian Right’s theologian in chief during a rally in Battle Creek, Mich., held at the same moment he was being impeached.
Because the president has perfected a uniquely American brand of political sadism, he launched into a mocking recitation of a conversation he claims to have had with Rep. Debbie Dingell, D-Mich., the widow of John Dingell, the longest-serving congressman in history who died earlier this year. Ms. Dingell is serving in his seat.
Mr. Trump claimed that Ms. Dingell thanked him for honoring her husband during a condolence call. She was allegedly so grateful to Mr. Trump for lowering flags over Washington to memorialize him that she also said, “He’s looking down, he’d be so thrilled.”
Exercising the damnation powers given to him by his cult of religious enablers, Mr. Trump was quick with a quip cruel even by Trumpian standards: “Maybe he’s looking up, I don’t know?” he said playfully intimating that John Dingell is in hell. The next morning, Michigan’s establishment Republicans were calling on Mr. Trump to apologize to the Dingell family. Even a few anchors and reporters at Fox News were shocked.
But as we all know, Mr. Trump is a creature of the moment. The laughter that ensued at the rally certainly contradicts the chorus of a favorite Christian hymn that has become popular since the ’70s: “They will know we are Christians / by our love / by our love / they will know we are Christians / by our love.”
But as two Republican congressmen made clear, Mr. Trump’s impeachment is a bigger miscarriage of justice than any melodrama involving a cross and an itinerant rabbi a couple of millennia ago.
“When Jesus was falsely accused of treason, Pontius Pilate gave Jesus the opportunity to face his accusers,” Mr. Loudermilk said without embarrassment during the impeachment vote. “During that sham trial, Pontius Pilate afforded more rights to Jesus than Democrats have afforded this president in this process.”
“So I want Democrats voting for impeachment today to know that I’ll be praying for them,” pious Mr. Keller said during his sackcloth and ashes moment on the House floor. “From the Gospel of Luke, the 23rd chapter, verse 34: And Jesus said, ‘Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.’”
The notion of Donald Trump getting a rawer deal than Jesus got from Pilate the day he was crucified only makes sense in a world where the criteria for truth and justice are dictated by Mr. Trump himself.
Just imagine Jesus, beaten, spat upon, stripped naked, hanging from a cross and bleeding like a stuck pig while the soldiers who tortured him look on. Imagine him hanging between two criminals half expecting him to pull a Houdini at the last second given his reputation.
Now, imagine the conversation between Jesus and the repentant thief as their final hour approaches according to the Cult of Trump’s grandiose theology:
Thief: “Any tricks left up your sleeves, boss? We could really use an intervening miracle about now.”
Jesus: “Oh, ye of little faith! How dare you ask me to save you from the righteous consequences of your sins at a time like this! Don’t you know that as bad as our situation is, it is nothing compared to what my faithful servant Donald Trump will experience in 2,000 years when he is unjustly impeached? If paradise is full of such self-centered wretches as you, it will be an eternal drag, indeed.”
Of course this is absurd, but it is only a slight exaggeration beyond what Mr. Trump’s most ardent followers effectively believe. In many ways, Mr. Trump’s impeachment is his crude way of “dying for the sins” of the MAGA crowd. He’s being “persecuted” just as they have been “persecuted” by “godless elites.”
That isn’t to say that his followers consider him “without sin.” The fact that he is just like them, with all of their warts, biases and character flaws, is what attracts them to him in the first place. Mr. Trump doesn’t have to die for anyone’s sins when he’s so good at reflecting them and glibly pronouncing them innocent.
That’s why for all of its absurdity, so many of Mr. Trump’s followers are comfortable with impeachment being used as a metaphor for the crucifixion. They assume that impeachment will only make Mr. Trump “stronger” and that a resurrection into a second term is just around the corner.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.