Jay Cost, a contributing opinion writer to the Post-Gazette and a contributing editor to The Weekly Standard, lives in Butler County (JCost241@gmail.com, Twitter @JayCostTWS).
•
In the winter of 1792, James Madison wrote, “Public opinion sets bounds to every government, and is the real sovereign in every free one.” In a system with free and fair elections, it is the views of the people — not some elite — that ultimately prevail.
Of course, that does not mean that we the people will rule properly. We could be foolish or unjust. What we require, Madison reckoned, is a broad “intercourse of sentiments.” We need to talk freely and openly with each other, to think about the issues of the day and to settle among ourselves on the best course of action.
This sort of public discourse is particularly challenging in the Age of Trump. The presidential office has long had enormous influence over public opinion, but no occupant has ever wielded it the way Donald Trump does. He is like a circus ringmaster, and we are transfixed by the performance. Love him or despise him, we seem unable to discuss politics without returning to Mr. Trump, who inevitably riles us up.
Take, for instance, the firing of Andrew McCabe, former deputy director of the FBI. Mr. Trump said on Twitter that this was a “a great day for democracy,” which provoked howls of outrage from his critics. Republican Sen. Jeff Flake, a longtime Trump antagonist, said it was in fact a “horrible day” for democracy.
Really? The firing of an otherwise obscure bureaucrat was either a “great” or “horrible” day for democracy? Maybe it was neither. Maybe American democracy was more or less OK with Mr. McCabe and will be more or less OK now that he is gone. After all, hardly any of us knew who he was before this kerfuffle, so maybe in the grand scheme this is a total irrelevance.
But that is what Mr. Trump does. He says something extreme that gins people up, one way or another, thereby reorienting the conversation around himself. This has been his marketing strategy for 30-plus years. In “The Art of the Deal,” he called it “truthful hyperbole.” He wrote that people “get very excited by” those who “always think big,” like Mr. Trump himself. He’s used this marketing strategy to turn himself into the main character in American politics — be it villain or hero, depending on your perspective.
There are at least two problems with this. First, it is exhausting. Let’s face it: Mr. Trump is living rent-free in many people’s heads these days — as is clearly evidenced by the often hyperbolic reactions to Mr. Trump’s use of “truthful” hyperbole. That is just not a healthy way to live — perpetually anxious and detached from the rather mundane reality that our democracy will, in all likelihood, continue to muddle along, just as it always has.
Second, return to Madison’s view on public opinion and ask yourself: How can public opinion be a wise and just sovereign when people are obsessed with Mr. Trump? The political discourse has become oriented not around the big challenges we face, but the circus master who resides at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. As a consequence, we are not really discussing the issues that matter — at least insofar as they do not relate to the person of Trump. So, we the people do not have the time or, for that matter, the mental reserves to think about the challenges facing the country, come to some kind of consensus and give our political leaders guidance on what should be done.
This, to me, is the much bigger problem. It is not that our system of government is under imminent danger, as Mr. Trump’s critics suggest. It is more like it is drifting sideways, absent informed judgments from the people. With Mr. Trump at the center of politics, we are unable to think about anything else, and thus don’t get much of anything done.
Put aside the hyperbolic responses to Mr. Trump — about how the “republic is being corrupted” or our “democracy is being hijacked” or whatever — and we still must admit that our 24/7 Trump mania is a deeply lamentable lost opportunity.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.