These days, everybody is talking about “fake news” — the spread of false information about the world around us. Liberals complain about talk radio, blogs, the Drudge Report and Fox News spreading misinformation, while conservatives gripe about mainstream media outlets that seem to make big mistakes with too much frequency. And nobody knows how to stop false stories from spreading like wildfire over Facebook and other social media.
The causes of fake news are varied and complex, but I think ultimately the American news consumer is to blame for this sorry state of affairs.
It used to be that Americans understood that reliable information about the world was a valuable commodity. If they wanted it, they knew they had to pay for it — in the form of subscriptions to newspapers and magazines. Now, far too many of us presume that we can get the same information for free. But that is not true. It is expensive to collect information about our complicated world — and increasingly, the modern news industry lacks the resources to do it the way it used to. And fake news is filling this gap.
Newspaper subscriptions for digital access have risen this year, but there is no mistaking the overall trend of the last generation: People have shifted away from print media. According to the Pew Research Center, daily and weekend subscriptions to newspapers have fallen by an average of about 3 percent per year. Advertising revenue has declined accordingly, which has led to massive cutbacks in staff. According to Pew, more than 56,000 people were employed in newsrooms in 2000, but that number plummeted to under 33,000 in 2014.
The new generation of journalists is often cut from quite a different cloth than those from years gone by. Many of today’s scribes are too young to understand fully how politics, policy or international relations really works. And they are obsessed with their “profiles.” How many Twitter followers do I have? How many TV spots have I gotten in this week? How many clicks has my article received on the web?
The decline of the old newspaper reporters and the inexperience, youth and self-obsession of the new breed of journalists have had a huge impact. Last year, Ben Rhodes, a foreign policy adviser to President Barack Obama at the time, explained the evolution to The New York Times Magazine in stark terms: “All these newspapers used to have foreign bureaus. Now they don’t. They call us to explain to them what’s happening in Moscow and Cairo. Most of the outlets are reporting on world events from Washington. The average reporter we talk to is 27 years old, and their only reporting experience consists of being around political campaigns. That’s a sea change. They literally know nothing.”
The internet has also created problems. As news consumption has shifted from print to web, the profit motive has shifted toward digital ad revenue, which has influenced the kind of news that is produced. Rather than get the important stories correct, so people continue to subscribe to the paper, websites try to create an endless stream of new content, to generate as much traffic as possible. Inevitably, quality is sacrificed and editorial standards are loosened as websites endeavor to appeal to the lowest common denominator.
Cable television is a problem, too. Click on Fox, CNN or MSNBC, and you will find an ever-rotating cast of television pundits, yelling at each other about the headlines of the day. That is how the cable networks drive ratings, and thus ad revenue, but this hardly informs people.
With all these negative changes in the news business, is it any wonder that irresponsible bloggers, social media cranks, cable-news hucksters and talk radio buffoons have filled the void with fake news?
If we really want to put a stop to fake news, we have to recognize that it costs a lot of money to collect and disseminate real news. And, like everything else in this world, we have to pay for it.
Jay Cost, a senior writer for The Weekly Standard, lives in Butler County (JCost241@gmail.com, Twitter @JayCostTWS).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.