Can men and women truly be friends? Depends on what you mean by "friends." In one sense the answer obviously is yes. It happens all the time, with no romantic or sexual contact involved.

Rick Nowlin is a Post-Gazette news assistant (rnowlin@post-gazette.com).

But let's be real. Guys, fellow heterosexuals, have you noticed that the atmosphere in your car is different with a woman in the passenger seat, no matter who she is or what you're doing? Yeah, I thought so.

Even in this enlightened era -- after the birth of the women's movement, after Title IX gave women access to academic and athletic opportunities they previously didn't have, after millions of women have claimed roles in politics, business, the military and other pursuits that traditionally were open only to men -- there remains the catnip of that special, inexplicable feminine essence that the presence of another man simply can't duplicate.

Advertise with us

The feminine mystique is at least part of the reason adolescent boys of all ages play sports or musical instruments, in the hope that they might gain the attention or approval of the person whom "Wild at Heart" author John Eldredge, borrowing from Robert Bly's "Iron John," called the "Golden-Haired Woman." It's not simply, or perhaps even primarily, a sexual thing; it's as much a spiritual matter -- dare I call it worship?

Whatever it is, it's why we still have cheerleaders, homecoming queens and Miss America pageants. It's why the chivalry of the Arthurian legends still holds so much potency, even though it is often dismissed as hopelessly old-school. It's why football players often mouth the words "Hi, Mom!" whenever a TV camera points their way. It's why Dad often has such a hard time when his daughter begins dating or, worse, when he escorts her down the aisle to hand her over to another man. It's why we have, sadly, such things as porn flicks and "lad mags," including the annual swimsuit edition of Sports Illustrated.

Jazz musician Branford Marsalis, a former clarinetist, once said that he switched instruments because someone told him, "You can get women with a saxophone." (As a sax player myself, I dispute that. But that's for another day.)


I met Sharon during my church's singles retreat in March 2004. She's not a classic beauty and I've seen her in a dress exactly twice. She's friendly and approachable and we talk or e-mail regularly. I can safely say that we've become good friends.

Advertise with us

That said, I still find myself flirting with her from time to time. Despite our friendship -- and it's not going any further than that -- she'll never be just one of the boys. I learned two days before Memorial Day of the following year that she's apparently OK with that.

That evening, after an afternoon of hiking in Ohiopyle State Park, a yearly ritual of the singles ministry at her church, Sharon, two other men and I headed into Greensburg to attend its annual carnival. After about an hour of checking out the booths around Lynch Field, we inadvertently stepped into the mythical moment. She asked, "Any of you guys want to win me a prize?"

Translated: Would any of you brave, gallant knights care to gain the favor of this fair maiden by slaying a dragon?

(She said later that she was kidding, but she didn't need to ask a second time.)

Though I certainly wasn't rescuing the proverbial damsel in distress, I at once started searching for an appropriate dragon's lair to get down to business. Just ahead loomed the basketball shoot and, having once been an avid hoopster, I figured I had a shot (pun intended). I gave the attendant $5, which gave me three chances, and then resolutely removed my Post-Gazette windbreaker, as if I were putting on armor. ("He's serious!" I heard somebody say. Darn right I was.)

Advertise with us

Alas, my first two attempts missed badly, and with only $6 more in my wallet I was hoping to avoid a trip to the ATM. That dragon -- er, ball -- was going down no matter how much money or time it cost me.

After a deep breath, once more I flung the ball toward the hoop -- the shot was again off line, this time to the right, but it drew iron, kissed the backboard, ricocheted backward, hopped several times, lingered on the left side of the rim ... and finally fell through.

Yesss!I swung my fist in jubilation.


Sharon chose a toy Dalmatian, which measured about half of her not-quite-five-foot height. The way she held her new pet was so cute that another member of our party took a picture with his camera phone; every time she calls him, he can have that picture pop up.

Advertise with us

After the fireworks, she drove two of us back to her church outside of town, where I had parked, and as I exited the back seat I noticed her prize in the hatch facing straight ahead.

On the drive home I understood that, in luring me to spend the 40 bits to win her the dog, Sharon had managed to touch my male soul -- the need to feel competent, to be able to come through for her in the clutch -- in a place that another guy just can't reach. Maybe I got the real prize that night, so I presented her with a thank-you card at the picnic we attended two days later in Moraine State Park.

I therefore must agree with the amorous -- and malodorous -- cartoon skunk Pepe LePew, who once said, "Zere is very little difference between men and women.

"But -- Vive la difference!!"