Ironically, former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet died on international human rights day. Mr. Pinochet had become not only the poster child for dictatorship in Latin America, but also for the U.S. policy of supporting such dictators, in Latin America and elsewhere.
Daniel Kovalik is a labor and human rights lawyer living in Highland Park who has been involved in the promotion of human rights in Latin America and has traveled throughout the region for the past 20 years (Kovalik@usw.org).
Therefore, it also was fitting that the very week of Mr. Pinochet's death, outgoing U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan urged the United States to reclaim its commitment to democracy -- a commitment which Mr. Annan believes the United States has slowly forgotten since the end of World War II. This warning must be heeded, and the U.S. experience with Mr. Pinochet and other dictators and nefarious characters worldwide shows us why.
On Sept. 11, 1973, Augusto Pinochet led a violent coup against the elected government of President Salvador Allende, bringing an end to democratic rule in that country for the next 16-plus years. At the time of the coup, Chile had been the longest-standing constitutional democracy in Latin America -- something the United States would claim to support. However, because the United States did not like the left-leaning Mr. Allende, it chose to help foment the coup that toppled his government and then continue to support the Pinochet dictatorship even as its human rights crimes became apparent. Mr. Pinochet's regime ultimately was responsible for the torture and murder of at least 3,197 individuals.
None of this in dispute. As a Sept. 19, 2000, document released by the CIA revealed, the CIA "sought to instigate a coup" against Mr. Allende even before he took office in 1970. As the CIA related, it "was working with three different groups of plotters," all of which "made it clear that any coup would require the kidnapping of army Cmdr. Rene Schneider, who felt deeply that the constitution required that the army allow Allende to assume power."
The United States, not sharing this commitment to civilian rule, supported the abduction of Mr. Schneider. The CIA continued to assist two of the three coup-plotters, including Mr. Pinochet, through the time Mr. Allende was overthrown. Once the coup took place, the United States continued to support the Pinochet regime, including Manuel Contereras, who served as an agent of the CIA from 1974 to 1977 and went on to head Chile's intelligence agency, known as the DINA. The DINA, according to Amnesty International, "played a central role in the policy of systematic and widespread human rights violations in Chile."
The United States continued to support the Pinochet dictatorship even as Mr. Pinochet exported his repressive tactics, including the torture and killing of political opponents throughout the southern cone of South America.
Not only was it wrong, and indeed hypocritical, for the United States to support the Pinochet dictatorship, it was highly counterproductive. Indeed, the wave of anti-U.S. sentiment we now see throughout Latin America can be traced to the longstanding U.S. policy of supporting, and many times installing, brutal dictatorships in that region, not only in Chile, but also in Brazil, Argentina, Guatemala, El Salvador and Nicaragua, to name just the most notable examples.
In addition, the United States continues to support the military of Colombia -- by far the most brutal in the Western Hemisphere. The Colombian military is responsible for the torture and extra-judicial killing of tens of thousands of civilians and now is the third largest recipient of U.S. military aid in the world. It is not surprising that there is widespread resentment in the region against the United States.
The United States has sewed the seeds of resentment and hatred in the Middle East through similar means. To name just one example, the U.S. overthrow of the democratically elected government of Dr. Mohammad Mossadeq in Iran in 1953 and its installation of the brutal, one-party rule of the shah in his stead, has left enduring scars in that country and throughout the Middle East. The United States supported the shah and his intelligence agency SAVAK, which engaged in the mass torture and execution of political prisoners, until the forcible overthrow of his rule in 1979. Again, the U.S. decision to turn its back on democracy in Iran (because it was unhappy with President Mossadeq's plans to nationalize Iranian oil) was not only wrong, it has led to violent anti-U.S. sentiment in the Middle East.
As the United States decides the course of its future foreign policy in the face of its disastrous foray into Iraq, we must remember the lessons of our failed attempts to control the destiny of other nations -- attempts that have many times undermined the principles of democracy and freedom we espouse. The most important lesson is that interference in other nations, particularly through violent means, almost invariably leads to the opposite result than the one intended and ultimately to instability and the diminishment of U.S. influence and legitimacy in the world.
At this stage of history, we must focus our efforts on peaceful means of resolving conflicts, we must abandon our country's ungrounded faith in war as a means to bring about change and we must respect the sovereignty of other nations, even those we don't particularly like, as we would like others to accept ours. It is only through such means that our national security will be secured.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.