I read with great amusement Oliver Bateman’s “The ugly truth haunting Pittsburgh’s awesome real estate market” (Nov. 27). The highly opinionated Baltimore journalist H.L. Mencken’s negative observations about Pittsburgh have long haunted the city.

As Ted Muller wrote in the summer 1991 issue of Pittsburgh History, “H.L. Mencken did not create Pittsburgh’s dismal image, but his writing certainly added to it. HLM’s vigorous writing style and caustic wit made the negative image unforgettable. His journalistic portrayal of Pittsburgh suggests how an image could become bigger than life and in time present a serious obstacle for a city and its boosters.”

Of course, Mencken was not the first one. Historians often cite James Parton’s 1866 portrayal of Pittsburgh as “Hell with the lid taken off” or Herbert Spencer, writing in 1882, “6 months residence here [Pittsburgh] would justify suicide.” Muller’s article suggests that these types of attacks motivated Mayor David Lawrence and the Allegheny Conference, among others, to embark on Renaissance I to remake the city’s physical image at midcentury.

Is image destiny? Pittsburgh’s rebound as a modern tech center and eds and meds economy shows that others’ portrayals of the region are not accurate. The resiliency of the city and region demonstrates that any amount of bad press can be overcome (if only our weather would cooperate).

Advertise with us

Dan Holland

Friendship