State Senator Dan Laughlin recently compared Texas Republicans’ current mid-census gerrymander to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s 2018 decision in League of Women Voters v. Commonwealth, which ended partisan gerrymandering in Pennsylvania (“Let the parties redraw the congressional map,” Aug. 29). That comparison is wrong.
In 2011, Republicans engineered a congressional map as part of “Project REDMAP,” a national plan to guarantee a Republican advantage. They created a map with contorted and nonsensical districts that numerous experts testified ignored all of the appropriate criteria for redistricting — compactness, preserving counties and municipalities, and so on — in favor of obtaining a Republican advantage.
The map made sure that even though Pennsylvania voters were roughly evenly supportive of Democrats and Republicans, the latter would have a virtually permanent 13–5 majority of Congressional seats.
The Supreme Court correctly held that their efforts violated the Pennsylvania Constitution’s Free and Equal Elections Clause, which dates back to 1776 and prohibits politicians from using their legislative power to artificially inflate their political power regardless of what voters want. The Court asked the Republican-controlled Legislature (including Sen. Laughlin) to submit a map that complied with the Clause, and it failed to do so. So the Court adopted a map that optimized the traditional criteria and reflected the roughly even support of the parties among voters (although it still gave Republicans a slight structural advantage).
The decision ended gerrymandering in Pennsylvania. It spared us from being part of the political circus unfolding in Texas and elsewhere.
Let us not confuse the cure with the disease.
Corrie Woods
Peters




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.