I completely agree with how David Mills ended his column on Christmas, “The answer to the murderer’s question” (Dec. 26). We are our brother’s keeper. We each are implicated in these stories.

A woman with a story yet to be uncovered was lit on fire last weekend on the NY subway (“Woman dies after being set on fire in subway car, police say,” Dec. 22). The perpetrator was many things, including being in the country illegally. But there are others in the story too — the silent one who filmed it, a uniformed policeman who walked on by, others watching.

All had coats on. None threw their coat on the woman to douse the flames.

Were the do-nothings coming or going to a job where they care for others? Did the policeman earlier that day help someone in need or make others feel safe just by his presence? I bet the woman who burned to death, if she saw him walk past, did not feel safer.

Advertise with us

“Am I my brother’s keeper?” asked Cain, with an attitude we all recognize as we hide our own guilt. A good lesson would be to diagram every person in this story, and the people behind the scenes, like parents and shelter workers — who were part of the story of how this man ended up caring nothing for another human, and how this probably homeless woman was almost lifeless on the train before she was lit on fire.

Then discuss what came before in the lives of those who did nothing, or worse, watched or filmed. And ask: where are you in this story. Because, we are each in the story. Again and again I hear God’s answer to Cain and to you and me. It is always yes.

Laurie Cunningham

Point Breeze