I was disappointed by Rabbi Seth Adelson’s simplistic and one-sided op-ed in last Sunday’s Post-Gazette (“Seeking return after a painful year,” Oct. 6). While demonizing the Hamas incursion into Israel last October, resulting in 1200 deaths, mostly of civilians, he makes no mention of the more than 41,000 Palestinians, mostly civilians, killed by the Israeli army in Gaza over the past year.
Nor does he mention Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, now in its 57th year. While Israel’s stranglehold on Gaza’s borders, depriving it of adequate food, clean water and medicine, has been repeatedly condemned by human rights organizations and UN agencies, Israeli politicians joked about “putting Gaza on a diet” and “mowing the lawn” with periodic air strikes.
We’re constantly reminded that Israel has a right to defend itself, but apparently Lebanese and Palestinians do not enjoy the same right. But to quote Rabbi Hillel, “If I am not for myself, who will be for me?”
Hezbollah arose in response to Israel’s 18 year occupation of south Lebanon, and Hamas came into being in response to Israel’s occupation of Gaza and its forceful response during the first (largely nonviolent) intifada.
Instead of urging restraint while supplying Israel with weapons and ammunition to continue its assault on Gaza, the Biden administration and other world leaders should begin the enormous task of determining who will be responsible for providing food, medicine and shelter to Gaza’s one and a half million inhabitants when the fighting ends — and who will guarantee that Gaza isn’t taken over by Israeli settlers once Palestinians find temporary housing elsewhere.
Leila Richards
Point Breeze




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.